MENU
Documenting
war crimes in Ukraine

The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

Crimean activist sentenced for “Down with the Putin police regime!” & social media postsRussia sentences poet Aleksandr Byvshev to 7 years for writing of its war crimes in Ukraine FSB violently detain renowned activist and Crimean Tatar National Assembly delegate Execution or Siberian labour camp for opposing Russia’s occupation of Ukrainian territory Russia's armed terror against independent Crimean Tatar Muslim community hits resistance Russia moves to confiscate possessions for condemning its war against Ukraine or for opposing occupation of Crimea Russia bans greeting ‘Glory to Ukraine’, labelling it ‘Nazi’ Russia raids Jehovah’s Witnesses in occupied Mariupol, claiming they ‘finance Ukraine’s Armed Forces’Russian invaders vandalize and plunder remembrance of Holodomor in occupied Ukraine At least 89 civilians abducted from occupied Ukraine since 2022 charged by aggressor state with 'terrorism' Crimean artist Bohdan Ziza's 15-year ‘terrorism’ sentence for opposing Russia’s war against Ukraine Imprisoned Russian poet Alexander Byvshev charged with ‘calls to terrorism’ for poem condemning Russia’s war against UkraineProminent lawyer defending Ukrainian political prisoners jailed in Russian-occupied Crimea Russia sentences Ukrainian Jehovah’s Witnesses to long terms of imprisonment for refusing to renounce their faithMove to criminalize protest over political and religious persecution in Russia and occupied Ukraine as ‘justification of extremism’Prominent Crimean Tatar journalist 'sentenced' by Russian court to 6 years for Facebook post about saving Oleh Sentsov's lifeCrimean imprisoned for ‘discrediting Russia’s army’ and its war crimes in Ukraine on social media Two Ukrainians face long sentences for Bible studies in Russian-occupied Crimea Russia detains and prosecutes elderly activists for flying the Crimean Tatar Flag Crimean artist sentenced to 15 years for protest over Russia’s war against Ukraine

Crimean left-wing activist arrested, drugged and charged with ‘extremism’

25.02.2019   
Halya Coynash
Valery Bolshakov asserts that he began facing persecution after a single-person picket against the Russian authorities

The ‘trial’ is continuing in Russian-occupied Crimea of Valery Bolshakov, a left-wing activist charged with ‘public calls to carry out extremist activities’.  Bolshakov is facing a possible three-year prison sentence for social media posts in which the Russian Investigative Committee perceived calls to overthrow the regime of Russian President Vladimir Putin.  Bolshakov only discovered that he was supposed to have ‘confessed’ to such calls after lawyer Alexei Ladin took on the case.

Both Bolshakov and his lawyer consider the prosecution to be politically motivated.  Bolshakov asserts that he began facing persecution after a single-person picket against the Russian authorities.

The initial charges laid against Bolshakov back in November 2017 were of ‘incitement to enmity’ with the alleged target of this enmity being Terek Cossacks.  That charge, under Article 282 § 1  of Russia’s criminal code, was recently withdrawn after a very modest improvement in an article widely abused to persecute people for social media reposts or posts.  The first prosecution of supposed incitement is now under administrative legislation.

The limitations of this apparent easing of the law can be seen clearly in this case where Bolshakov is facing other charges over the same social media posts. He was charged in January 2018 under Article 280 §§ 1 and 2 with alleged calls to commit ‘extremist activities’, and the more serious charge of the same calls with the use of the mass media.  It is the latter charge that could carry a sentence of up to three years’ imprisonment.  Russia’s legislation on so-called ‘extremism’ has elicited international criticism, with the term so loose that it can be and usually is used against those exercising their right to freedom of speech on social media or elsewhere.

The Russian-controlled prosecutor in Sevastopol claims that the posts called to hostile actions towards the same group of people, namely Terek Cossacks.  During the ‘court hearing’ on 22 February, the prosecutor also interrogated Bolshakov on his opinion about Vladimir Lenin’s pronouncement that “power can only be seized by force”.

Bolshakov denies the charges and says that his utterances have been falsely interpreted.  He also alleges that after the search of his apartment, he was taken to what he terms the police station where ambulance medics injected him, against his will, with some unknown substance. He says that he felt bad after the injection, that he felt intoxicated and half-sleepy, as well as getting a headache and eye pain.

He asserts that it was the ‘investigator’ who wrote the explanation in which Bolshakov was supposed to have confessed to calls to change the regime, to extremist activities and to insulting officers from the Investigative Committee.

The protocol claimed that Bolshakov had read out his network and IP addresses by heart, as well as reciting verbatim the statements on social media which he is charged in connection with.  Bolshakov pointed out that this protocol had been drawn up without a lawyer present, and he questioned that the signatures on it were his. A second protocol, drawn up later with a lawyer,  differs significantly from the first.

Bolshakov is one of two Crimean left-wing activists facing these charges, with the other Yevhen Karakashev imprisoned since 1 February 2018.  Those arrests coincided with arrests of left-wing activists in Russia.

With the contempt for the presumption of innocence standard in Russia and, now, in occupied Crimea, both Bolshakov and Karakhashev have been added to Russia’s notorious ‘List of Terrorists and Extremists’.  This means that even Bolshakov, who has not been placed in detention, still faces major difficulties in getting money out of his own bank account, etc. 

The renowned Memorial Human Rights Centre has added Karakashev, who remains in detention, to its list of likely victims of political persecution.

 Share this