MENU
Documenting
war crimes in Ukraine

The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

Russian court rejects appeal against extradition of asylum seekerRussia’s Supreme Court cancels the expulsion of refugee to UzbekistanReal terrorists free to act while Russian FSB tortures political prisoners for 'good statistics' Russia uses Siberia for maximum vengeance against imprisoned Crimean Tatar journalist Remzi Bekirov and his family Russia frees criminals, sentences Crimean Tatar civic journalist to 11 years for moral integrityRussian justice: murderers pardoned for killing Ukrainians, Crimean Tatas sentenced to 17 years for defending political prisoners Crimean Tatar political prisoner: Russia’s 19-year sentence will not silence me, nor will such persecution break others Russian FSB seize Crimean Tatar family’s last son in new wave of terror against Crimean Solidarity activists13-year sentences for somebody else's conversation in cynical rehash of Russia's first attack on Crimean Tatar rights activists Russia sentences human rights defender to 14 years for helping political prisoners seek justice from ECHR Russia effectively sentences veteran Crimean Tatar activist to death for somebody else’s voice on a tapeRussia sentences blind and disabled Ukrainian to 17 years for discussing politics and religion Russia flouts UN order and begins carrying out death sentence against Crimean Tatar civic journalist Russia sentences Crimean Tatar political prisoner to 11 years for free thinking and civic activismUN Committee orders Russia to refrain from killing second Crimean Tatar political prisoner in one monthRussia terminates ‘trial’ of refugee it killed in occupied Crimea two years ago Prayers for Peace are Forbidden: a Digest of Russian ProtestsCourt sentences conscientious objector to a year in jailDeath sentence for reporting on Russian repression in occupied Crimea and chilling repeat of Stalin-era persecution Russia challenged over Crimean Tatar civic journalist’s death sentence

European Court of Human Rights halts extradition of Uzbek asylum seeker from Russia

24.04.2008   

On 22 April 2008 the European Court decided that Dilshod Kurbanov, whose extradition on politically motivated charges of a religious nature is demanded by the Uzbekistan authorities, must not be extradited from Russia pending further notification. The relevant documents were passed to the Government of the Russian Federation via the RF Representative at the European Court.

Dilshod Kurbanov was detained in the Tula region on 30 May 2007 because the Uzbekistan law enforcement agencies had placed him on the wanted list.

In June that year, from the SIZO [pre-trial detention centre], he sent an application for refugee status in the Russian Federation, since in Uzbekistan he is accused of taking part in prohibited Islamic organizations and movements which he categorically denies.

This application was rejected on 9 April 2008. It should be mentioned that the Federal Migration Service ignored the conclusions of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) Mission in Russia who found that Kurbanov is in need of international protection and must not be returned to Uzbekistan

On 18 April 2008 the Tula Regional Court rejected Kurbanov’s appeal against the decision of the Russian Federation Prosecutor General (from 26 December 2007) to extradite him to his country of origin to face criminal charges of “encroachment on the constitutional system of the Republic of Uzbekistan” (Article 159) and “preparation or distribution of material containing a threat to public safety and order” (Article 244-1) of the Uzbekistan Criminal Code.

As already reported, the charges are the standard fare used in Uzbekistan against Muslims persecuted for their religious beliefs.

We also reported earlier the grounds given for refusing to recognize Kurbanov a refugee.  They are extraordinary enough to warrant repetition. The Head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs Department for the Tula Region asserts that in the charges against Kurbanov “there is no sign of a political motive for the prosecution” and “according to information from the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Uzbekistan government denies the existence of torture.” He also claims that “the Russian Federal Migration Service has no facts concerning persecution of citizens on ethnic and religious grounds”.

The Russian Federation Prosecutor General and Tula Regional Court saw fit to ignore the norms of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and the UN Convention against Torture prohibiting sending people back to countries where they could be subjected to torture.

It is important to note that the application to the European Court of Human Rights to apply Rule 39 was based on the well-founded fear that Kurbanov would face torture if returned. Strasbourg accepted these grounds and has halted the extradition.

This is at least the sixth time that applications have been made to the Court in connection with the threat that people persecuted for their religious convictions in Uzbekistan will be forcibly returned there from Russia.

In two cases, the Russian Federation breached the instructions from Strasbourg. Rustam Muminiov was handed over to the Uzbekistan authorities in October 2006 and was later sentenced to 5.5 years imprisonment. In December 2007, Abdugani Kamaliyev (Tursinov) was illegally expelled, despite more than 24 hours having passed since the notification from the European Court of Human Rights was received. He was sentenced in Uzbekistan to 11 years imprisonment.

In both cases, the Russian authorities claimed that they had not had enough time to respond. Since the period allowed for an appeal against the Tula Court’s ruling has not expired, such an excuse cannot possibly be used on this occasion.

Based on a report by Yelena Ryabinina of the Civic Assistance Committee

тел. +7-903-197-04-34

 Share this