login | registration | forgot the password
today 29.09.2016 20:05
(by Kyiv time)


Kharkiv Human Rights Group Social Networking

Russian ítrialí of Putinís hostage to continue despite Ukrainian court verdict

28.05.15 | Halya Coynash

A Russian court has refused to terminate the trial of veteran Crimean Tatar leader Mustafa Dzhemilievís son Khaiser, despite a verdict and sentence having been passed on the 33-year-old Ukrainian national by a Ukrainian court and his extradition requested. The judgeís Ďargumentí was that there had been no verdict from a Russian court.

Khaiser Dzhemilievís lawyer Nikolai Polozov points out that Russiaís own Criminal Code (Article 12 ß 3) makes it clear that a sentence passed in Ukraine is sufficient grounds for terminating his clientís prosecution in Russia.† Furthermore, in Russia, just as in Ukraine and other countries, a person cannot be tried twice on the same charges. †This is enshrined in Russiaís Constitution (Article 50 ß 1, with Article 62 ß 3 of the same document indicating that this applies also to foreign nationals).

At the court hearing, Polozov produced a copy of the court sentence passed on Dzhemiliev by a district court in Kyiv on April 10, 2015.† Khaiser Dzhemiliev was found guilty of manslaughter; theft of a weapon and ammunition and illegal possession of both.† He was sentenced to 3 years and 8 months imprisonment, with this counted from the day of his arrest †Ė May 27, 2013. †The sentence was not appealed and has now come into force. †Ukraine has since lodged an application for his extradition which has thus far not been answered.

The sentence was in full accord with the previous rulings from Ukrainian courts from early 2014 which reinstated the original charges of manslaughter and ordered Khaiserís release from custody.† This order was then confirmed by the European Court of Human Rights which on July 10, 2014 applied Rule 39, ordering that Dzhemiliev be freed. Despite the binding nature of all rulings and decisions from the Court in Strasbourg, Russia has not only failed to comply, but has moved Khaiser to Krasnodar in Russia and already begun his trial.† The prosecution has ignored the charges laid back at the time of the tragic shooting in May 2013 of manslaughter through carelessness and is accusing Khaiser of Ďmurder out of hooligan motivesĒí.

This refusal to terminate the proceedings despite the sentence already passed is surely further confirmation of Mustafa Dzhemilievís statement that the Kremlin is applying open blackmail in holding his son in prison. †The 71-year-old Crimean Tatar leader, whom Russia has banned from entering his homeland or Russia and who can therefore not even see his son, has from the outset been implacably opposed to Russiaís invasion and annexation of Crimea.†

It was the regime of Viktor Yanukovych back in 2013 that first threatened that if Mustafa Dzhemiliev did not go along with them, his son would be charged with murder, not manslaughter. This use of court prosecutions as a method of hostage-taking is now being continued by Russia. .

In May 2013 Khaiser Dzhemiliev shot and killed Fevzi Edemov who was working as a guard to the family.† All the evidence pointed to manslaughter, and all attempts to later claim murder attempts to bring pressure to bear on Khaiserís father who holds considerable authority among Crimean Tatars, in Ukraine and the world.

As with the ongoing detention and charges against film director Oleg Sentsov and civic activist Oleksandr Kolchenko, Russia has taken Ukrainian nationals by force to Russia and claimed that they have become citizens of Russia.† In the prosecution of Sentsov and Kolchenko, there was no terrorism at all to warrant the charges.† Khaiser Dzhemiliev committed an offence, but he did so under Ukrainian rule and Ukrainian legislation. However after a Ukrainian court sentenced him, Russian Judge Vladimir Kobzev could find nothing better to justify the Kremlinís hostage holding than to say that the Ukrainian verdict was ďnot RussianĒ.

The Ukrainian court acted in accordance with law.†

see also:
Attempt to foist Russian citizenship on Mustafa Dzhemilievís hostage son
Hostage to the End. Russia refuses to release Mustafa Dzhemilievís Son
Memorial demands that Russia return Mustafa Dzhemilievís hostage son to Ukraine
Russia refuses to extradite Crimean Tatar leader Mustafa Dzhemilievís hostage son
Mustafa Dzhemilievís hostage son punished in Russian captivity
Russia targets Mustafa Dzhemilievís hostage son in revenge for Crimea Blockade
Russian court reduces illegal sentence passed on Crimean Tatar leader Mustafa Dzhemilievís son
Russian court illegally jails Khaiser Dzhemiliev, son of world-renowned Crimean Tatar leader
Not Guilty! Russian jury rejects murder charges against Khaiser Dzhemiliev
Putinís Hostage: Russia tries Mustafa Dzhemilievís Son
Mustafa Dzhemilievís hostage son to be tried by jury in Russia
Trial in Russia imminent of Mustafa Dzhemilievís hostage son
Dzhemiliev: Russia guilty of open blackmail in holding my son in prison
Chubarov: Crimea is descending into Terror and Fear
Two young Crimean Tatars abducted
Moscow endorses offensive against Crimean Tatar Mejlis
Bakhchysarai Mejlis faces eviction after mysterious court hearing
Targeting the Crimean Tatar Mejlis as pro-Russian euphoria fades in Crimea
Crimean Tatar Mejlis given 24 hours to leave