17.02.2017 | Halya Coynash

Strasbourg to rule if Russia can ban Crimean Tatar Mejlis for opposing its occupation of Crimea

Mejlis attack colour

Ukraine is taking Russia to the European Court of Human Rights over its ban of the Mejlis or representative assembly of the Crimean Tatar People.  Russia’s criminalization of the self-governing body of the main indigenous people of Crimea has been described as “a hostile act against the Crimean Tatars” and as a new low for Russia.  The Mejlis has clearly been declared ‘extremist’ because of its opposition to Russian occupation, so it seems inconceivable that the Court in Strasbourg will not find Russia in grave violation of the European Convention.  The problem is chiefly the time taken to consider such cases, during which still more members of the Mejlis are likely to face imprisonment or other forms of repression. 

Pavlo Petrenko, Ukraine’s Justice Minister announced on Feb 9 that the application was being agreed with the Mejlis before being formally lodged.  It will be the sixth inter-state suit brought by Ukraine against Russia over the latter’s invasion and annexation of Crimea and its military aggression in Donbas.

Although the formal ruling banning the Mejlis was on April 26, 2016, with this upheld by the Russian Supreme Court on Sept. 29, repressive measures began shortly after Russia’s invasion and annexation of Crimea.  The Mejlis had called on all Crimean Tatars and other Ukrainians to boycott the pseudo-referendum with which Russia attempted to give legitimacy to its land-grab.  Veteran Crimean Tatar leader and former Mejlis leader Mustafa Dzhemiliev was banned from his homeland in April 2014, with a ban on the current Mejlis Head Refat Chubarov following in July that same year. 

The offensive against the Mejlis itself intensified in September 2014, after the Mejlis again called for a boycott of equally fraudulent ‘elections’.  Then in January 2015, Akhtem Chiygoz, the Mejlis’ Deputy Head was arrested and remains imprisoned on surreal and thoroughly lawless charges.  Another Mejlis leader Ilmi Umerov is also facing a 5-year jail sentence, quite literally for saying that Russia should be made to leave Crimea. 

The banning of the Mejlis as ‘extremist’ came in stages, probably to see how much condemnation there was abroad.  There was never more than ‘deep concern’ and  Russia moved from threats to specific action, with a ‘court application’ first lodged in February, 2016. The ban was then made a fait accompli on April 13 when the de facto prosecutor Natalya Poklonskaya announced that she was ‘suspending’ the Mejlis without a court ruling.  Russia’s justice ministry then also saw no need to await a court ruling and on April 18 added the Crimean Tatar Mejlis to its list of “civic or religious organizations whose activities have been suspended due to their extremist activities.”  The ban, as mentioned, was then rubber-stamped on April 26. Since it was immediately appealed, it has only been in force since the Supreme Court ruling on Sept 29. 

Thus far the occupation regime has confined itself to administrative proceedings over a Mejlis meeting, however prominent Crimean Tatar lawyer Emil Kurbedinov believes it is only a matter of time before a new offensive. 

It remains unclear how many people are in danger.  Local mejlis are autonomous bodies. If they are brought under the ban, then over 2 thousand people could be directly affected. The Crimean Tatar Mejlis is made up of 33 members. These are selected by the Qurultay which is elected by all Crimean Tatars. 

There are some organizations who have over the years been in opposition to the Mejlis.  Typically, Russia has pulled out one such marginal organization – Qurim Birligi – for an ‘appeal’ to the United Nations using Moscow’s arguments for recognizing Crimea as ‘Russian’ and lifting sanctions.

Opposing organizations were always in the minority, and this, if anything, has now increased with the Mejlis viewed by very many Crimean Tatars as a symbol of their identity and unity. 

Refat Chubarov reports that a special executive body has now been formed, functioning outside occupied Crimea.  The newly-elected body has 9 members including Mustafa Dzhemiliev. 

Just as Russia has persistently denied its invasion and its occupation of Crimea, it has equally implausibly tried to rewrite the facts regarding its extraordinary banning of a self-governing body, which the European Parliament, in a recent resolution. called “the legitimate representation of the Crimean Tatar community”.   The European Parliament’s recognition of the Crimean Tatars as an indigenous people of Crimea whose right to self-government is protected under the UN Declaration on Rights of Indigenous Peoples basically echoes the position taken by all democratic countries.

Russia, however, has tried to treat the Mejlis as a ‘civic organization’ which can be banned as ‘extremism’.  The attempt itself is absurd, but so too was the  ‘evidence’ provided at the court hearings.  These included: a document published by Mustafa Dzhemiliev back in Soviet times (1988); the Mejlis’ founding documents from two decades before Russia’s annexation.  Their supposed ‘extremism’ lay in the aim declared as being the reinstatement of the Crimean Tatar people’s national and political rights as part of Ukraine.  The other material presented included the notification of criminal proceedings lodged against Mustafa Dzhemiliev for having tried to enter his homeland; and against Refat Chubarov, for “encroaching upon Russia’s territory”, that is, opposing Russia’s occupation of his native Crimea.  The legally nihilistic charges against Akhtem Chiygoz regarding a pre-annexation demonstration on Feb 26, 2014, over which Russia has no jurisdiction were also put forward. 

There was more as well, with the Crimean Blockade claimed to have been ‘extremist’.  The Mejlis took no formal position on the Blockade, and the constant mention of Lenur Islyamov, the head of the Blockade, irrelevant.  He is not, nor never has been a member of the Mejlis.

‘Arguments’ of this nature were simply accepted by the Supreme Court which clearly understood its task as being to complete the completely illegal criminalization of the democratically elected and internationally recognized self-governing assembly of the Crimean Tatar people.  

Recommend this post


to post any message or commentary, you need to login »»

2017.04.08 | ypMs

botas de futbol

Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace

adidas outlet

Nike Shoes Sale Store

air force one pas cher

Nike Air Damen


cheap uggs for women

Cheap Toms Shoes Outlet

nike schuhe günstig

Soccer Boots Outlet nike

Pandora Official Website

louboutin heels

Yeezy Men

Jordan Sneakers For Sale

zapatillas nike baratas

Yeezy Boost Sale Online

Original Ugg Boots

cheap uggs

Nike Air Jordan 11

canada goose jackets on sale

Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher

Air Nike

Discount Air Max

Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel

pandora outlet store

ugg factory outlet

Nike Air Sneakers

Nike Shox discount Sale

Nike Soccer Cleats Boots

Canada Goose Womens Coats

religion store

nfl store

Jordan Shoes Air

zapatilla adidas

Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher

Nike Roshe Run Sale

Adidas Originals Superstar

hogan scontate

Nike Zapatos

official NHL jerseys

Cheap Toms Outlet Store

billige nike sko

Pandora Store

longchamp bags on sale

Ray Ban Sunglasses Online

Air Max Femme

pandora jewelry store

günstige nike schuhe


Pandora Store Sale

ugg clearance

nike air

Moncler Outlet Online

chaussure Nike homme

nike tn pas cher

nike mercurial soccer cleats

Adidas Superstar Sale Online

Pandora Store

Timberland Outlet

ugg store

Cheap Michael Kors

vans shoe store

scarpe nike

Nike Air 90

Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher

nike sneakers

Moncler Outlet Store

abercrombie and fitch store

retro jordans for cheap

Nike Air Max Cheap

zapatos de futbol nike

nike joggesko

Uggs Pas Cher Soldes

Descuentos Nike

Kobe Shoes Nike

Canada Goose Outlet

prada outlet

coach factory outlet online

converse store

Adidas Originals Stan Smith

Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace

Nike Air Women

uggs outlet

nike sportschuhe

Boty Nike Air

Nike Online Store

Boost Yeezy Sale On Line

christian louboutin outlet

zapatillas running

Nike Pas Cher Femme

Yeezy Black

Nike Shox Cheap

Air Max Pas Cher

Michael Kors Outlet

Oakley Sunglasses Cheap

adidas store

Michael Kors

Stone Island Outlet

Jordan Store

new jordan releases

Adidas Neo Discount Sale

Uggs For Cheap

huarache sneakers

reebok running shoes


Michael Kors Handbags Discount

Air Max Kopen

Ugg Pas Cher Femme

new pandora charms

Ugg boots Sale

Air max dam

suivre un envoi

womens nike air max

Discount TOMS

nike air max running shoes

Ugg Outlet Online Store

Cheap Air Max Trainers


Ray ban sale online

new yeezy shoes

23 IS BACK Store

Ugg Pas Cher En France

scarpe hogan outlet

nike sb stefan janoski

Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher

Canada Goose Outlet

Vans Black Sneakers

nike air jordan pas cher

Hogan Outlet

Nike Air Pas Cher

fitflops sale uk

chaussures nike pas cher

Toms Factory Outlet

Air Max 90

nike shoes

Nike Air Max Goedkoop

Toms Outlet Online

Negozi Pandora

pandora beads

Canada goose dam

Coach Bags On Sale

goedkope nike air max

Adidas Superstar

Scarpe Air Max

Official Toms Shoes Outlet

Nike Store

Air Max Sneakers

toms sale

moncler jacket sale

Yeezy Shoes Discount Marketplace

Air max levně

Air Jordan Retro Sale

Hugo Boss Sale

Jordan Schoenen

canada goose jacket outlet

chaussure basket homme

Nike Factory Store

nike jordan shoes

Moncler Sale

Boutique Ugg

TOMS For Sale

Nike Air Huarache For Sale

Cheap Michael Kors Tote Bag

cheap nike air max

Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace

toms shoes outlet

Ray-Ban Official Discounted Site

newest lebron shoes

ypMs 2017.4.8


forgot the password




send me a new password

on top