search  
print
14.02.2017 | Halya Coynash

Russia’s Constitutional Court finds law criminalizing peaceful protest ‘constitutional’

Дадин 2
   

There have been mixed reactions to the judgement passed by Russia’s Constitutional Court on Feb 10 on the draconian anti-protest law used to imprison peaceful protester  Ildar Dadin.  While Amnesty International saw a “chink of hope” in the order for a new examination of Dadin’s case, the Memorial Human Rights Centre was considerably less upbeat about Dadin’s chances for an early release and strongly criticized the judgement.

Dadin is the first Russian to have been imprisoned under the new Article 212.1 of the criminal code which was introduced in July 2014.  The article allows for criminal proceedings and a sentence of up to 5 years if a court has issued three rulings on administrative offences within 180 days.  It is quite standard in today’s Russia for police to detain people at entirely peaceful protests, with administrative protocols for supposed ‘infringements of the rules on holding public gatherings’ then drawn up and processed by the courts with no questions asked.  The norm had been widely criticized as unconstitutional from the outset, and seen as part of the offensive against civil society.   Rights groups pointed out that 212.1 imposes double punishment for the same actions, first via administrative legislation, then criminal, and effectively enables the criminalization of entirely peaceful protest. 

Dadin was sentenced to 3 years’ imprisonment, later reduced to 2.5, over 5 entirely peaceful protests or pickets.  He appealed to the Constitutional Court, challenging the law itself, rather than its application in his case.

The Court decided in a very long judgement that the article did not breach Russia’s Constitution, but it did recommend some amendments and that Dadin’s case be reviewed.

The Court stated that criminal liability for infringements at public events should be commensurate with the danger to the public of the actions.  Criminal liability should not be applied in cases where the infringements were merely formal and caused no harm.  The court needed also to provide the person’s intent to infringe established procedure for organizing or holding a public event.

It also stipulated that the administrative penalties must have come into force before any proceedings were initiated under Article 212.1.  

Amnesty International, which has declared Dadin a prisoner of conscience, was very positive about the judgement, with Denis Krivosheev calling it “a chink of light in an otherwise bleak outlook for the right to peaceful assembly in Russia”.  He believes it sends “a strong message to the authorities who have used this draconian legislation to persecute peaceful protesters like Ildar Dadin”. 

What message?

Kirill Koroteev, a lawyer for the Memorial Human Rights Centre, took a different position

“To explain the unconstitutionality of 212.1, 3-5 pages would have been sufficient, yet the judges wrote 43. They wrote a whole pile of exceptions to the article which are, in fact, complicated and based on value judgements. The CC judgement has made further application of 212.1 more difficult, but has not prevented it”.

He believes it quite likely that a new trial in Dadin’s case will still end in conviction.  They will find some way of skirting around the fact that the proceedings were initiated before all administrative penalties had taken effect, and will just question the police officers more to try to present the activities as ‘dangerous’. 

It is, unfortunately, very easy to imagine how that will be done.  If, up till now, any old ‘infringement of the rules on holding a public event’ would do, this may now change.  ‘Disobeying a police officer’ may be preferred since that could surely be presented as ‘harmful’ and demonstrating intent.  There could also be more use of provocateurs against solitary picketers.  The police can always choose to view the peaceful picketer and provocateur as mutually responsible for a supposed breach of the rules, with the conflict also being viewed as publicly dangerous. 

Ildar Dadin

Dadin’s lawyer Ksenya Kostromina has already applied to the Supreme Court for a review of her client’s case. 

As reported here, Dadin was sentenced on Dec 7, 2015 to 3 years’ medium security imprisonment.  Judge Natalya Dudar from Moscow’s notorious Basmanny Court added a year to the two-year sentence demanded by the prosecutor.  Judges at that court do not ‘pass’ sentences, they pass them on, and the decision to come down hard on the young activist almost certainly came from higher up.

Dadin is well-known to Ukrainians for his active support for Euromaidan.  Judging by the number of times this support came up during the trial, this almost certainly contributed to the harshness of the sentence (details here). 

In his final address to the court, Dadin stressed that he was not asking for anything, but simply defending his constitutional rights. 

The conviction was upheld at the end of March by Judge Natalya Borisova from the Moscow City Court, though reduced by 6 months. Borisova rejected Dadin’s application to be present in court, and his final words were spoken by video link from the SIZO [remand prison]. 

“I am here because I live in accordance with my conscience”, he said. “Until you come out and state your position, you are an accomplice to fascism. If we don’t catch our officials in the act, if we allow executioners to kill people, we are responsible”.  He called the sentence anti-constitutional, unlawful, unwarranted and criminal.

Hopefully Koroteev is overly pessimistic about the chances for Dadin’s release, however his frustration with the Court’s refusal to recognize the overt unconstitutionality of 212.1 will be widely shared. 

 

 

Recommend this post

comments

to post any message or commentary, you need to login »»

2017.03.10 | hyhMs

Nike Air Women


Boost Yeezy Sale On Line


Air Max Kopen


ugg clearance


TOMS SHOES OUTLET


Cheap Michael Kors


cheap nike air max


cheap uggs


Nike Air 90


Pandora Store


uggs for women


Air Max Pas Cher


scarpe nike


Kobe Shoes Nike


christian louboutin outlet


nike sportschuhe


zapatillas running


Hugo Boss Sale


Ray ban sale online


Descuentos Nike


nfl store


nike air


zapatilla adidas


Yeezy Men


nike air max running shoes


Scarpe Air Max


zapatillas nike baratas


toms sale


nike shoes


huarache sneakers


nike joggesko


Nike Factory Store


Adidas Originals Superstar


Air Nike


moncler outlet


Nike Air Jordan 11


pandora outlet store


Jordan Store


prada outlet


Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace


retro jordans for cheap


air force one pas cher


Nike Shox discount Sale


Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher


Ugg Pas Cher En France


günstige nike schuhe


ugg factory outlet


Jordan Shoes Air


The official UGG


adidas store


Hogan Outlet


Pandora Store


Canada Goose Outlet


billige nike sko


Ugg boots Sale


nike jordan shoes


Air Max 90


moncler jacket sale


womens nike air max


newest lebron shoes


Coach Bags On Sale


toms shoes outlet


uggs outlet


Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel


pandora beads


chaussure Nike homme


Air Max Sneakers


Yeezy Black


Nike Online Store


Adidas Originals Stan Smith


converse store


Boutique Ugg


Nike Shoes Sale Store


new jordan releases


canada goose jackets on sale


Vans Black Sneakers


Nike Air Damen


Jordan Sneakers For Sale


nike mercurial soccer cleats


Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace


Ray Ban Sunglasses Online


religion store


Michael Kors Outlet


vans shoe store


Air Max Femme


Michael Kors


nike sneakers


canada goose jacket outlet


ugg store


Canada Goose Womens Coats


hogan scontate


Nike Air Max Cheap


Nike Air Huarache For Sale


Yeezy Boost Sale Online


new yeezy shoes


Discount Air Max


Canada Goose Outlet


Canada goose dam


nike air jordan pas cher


Ugg Outlet Online Store


official NHL jerseys


Jordan Schoenen


Moncler Sale


Timberland Outlet


reebok running shoes


nike sb stefan janoski


Nike Air Sneakers


Nike Pas Cher Femme


Adidas Superstar


Adidas Neo Discount Sale


Uggs Pas Cher Soldes


cheap uggs for women


Nike Shox Cheap


Nike Store


Ugg Pas Cher Femme


Nike Zapatos


Adidas Superstar Sale Online


pandora jewelry store


ADIDAS NMD SALE ON LINE


new pandora charms


botas de futbol


Michael Kors Handbags Discount


Air Jordan Retro Sale


goedkope nike air max


Toms Outlet Online


nike tn pas cher


Oakley Sunglasses Cheap


Boty Nike Air


Pandora Official Website


Nike Roshe Run Sale


Uggs For Cheap


Negozi Pandora


Air max levně


longchamp bags on sale


zapatos de futbol nike


coach factory outlet online


Moncler Outlet Store


Moncler Outlet Online


Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher


Ray-Ban Official Discounted Site


louboutin heels


Nike Soccer Cleats Boots


Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher


fitflops sale uk


Stone Island Outlet


Soccer Boots Outlet nike


Nike Air Max Goedkoop


chaussures nike pas cher


adidas outlet


chaussure basket homme


Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace


scarpe hogan outlet


Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher


abercrombie and fitch store


Original Ugg Boots


Air max dam


nike schuhe günstig



hyhMs 2017.3.10

X




forgot the password

registration

X

X

send me a new password


on top