search  
print
02.03.2017 | Halya Coynash

Not the Right Way to Bring Yanukovych to Trial

Yanukovych in Rostov, Russia, Nov 2016, Photo EPA.png
   

Ex-President Viktor Yanukovych at a press conference in Rostov on the Don,  Photo: EPA 

First published by the Atlantic Council  

The Kremlin is well known for pulling former Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych out of hiding for its own purposes. Now Ukraine’s leaders have been accused of using Yanukovych as an excuse to push legislation that may have dangerous repercussions for Ukraine’s justice system—while not necessarily bringing Yanukovych and his cronies any closer to justice.

Yury Lutsenko, Ukraine’s prosecutor general, has been promising to begin Yanukovych’s trial in absentia in March this year. The move and legislative amendments required for that to occur have clearly been coordinated with President Petro Poroshenko. There is considerably less enthusiasm from Serhiy Horbatyuk, the chief investigator into crimes against Maidan activists, as well as from lawyers representing the families of Maidan victims and from other civic activists.


This is not a question of whether Yanukovych and others should be held to account in a court of law. The problem is ensuring that any conviction is fully in keeping with the law and will not be legitimately challenged in international courts. It is worth noting that the criticism is coming from experienced lawyers, while the main lobbyists for the bill—and this includes Lutsenko—are essentially politicians.

Lutsenko is hoping to try Yanukovych on several charges: of usurping power, undermining the armed forces’ defense capacity, and state treason. Ukraine’s parliament adopted amendments in May 2016 enabling trial in absentia; they allow for pre-trial investigation if a person is on the wanted list, but are valid only until April 15, 2017. Amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC) that remove the problem with time limits are being proposed in a draft law currently before parliament.

Draft bill 5610, if passed, will also increase the timeframe to eighteen months for a criminal investigation in which a person is in hiding; additionally, it will allow people accused of serious crimes committed by a criminal or terrorist organization to be detained for eighteen months.

Before the vote on the bill on February 23, Lutsenko told MPs that once it was adopted, 119 criminal prosecutions against Yanukovych, his former Interior Minister Vitaly Zakharchenko, as well as people suspected of involvement in the gunning down of Maidan protesters would be passed to the courts.
Lutsenko has repeatedly claimed that Russian citizens like Sergei Glazyev, Russian President Vladimir Putin’s adviser, and the Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu would fall under the law. There are almost certainly grounds for seeking their prosecution in the International Criminal Court, but it is difficult to see how a life sentence against Glazyev passed by a Ukrainian court on charges of crimes against peace and international order would achieve anything more than publicity.

Carte blanche for abuse

The bill has been roundly condemned by Oleksandr Banchuk from the Centre for Legal and Political Reform, who says that Poroshenko and Lutsenko are using the effort to put Yanukovych on trial as a pretext for a major offensive against Ukrainians’ rights.

He warns of the impact on ordinary citizens if the law is passed. Up until now, it has been understood that a person cannot be tried in absentia, and that the person must be informed that they are under suspicion, charged, or that the case has been passed to the court. While trial in absentia for particularly grave crimes may remain the exception, the CPC’s amendments could lead to dangerous abuse. Article 135 § 2 would now read that if a person is believed to be outside Ukraine, a notification would be sent to their last known residence and published in official publications.

Many Ukrainians do not live where they are officially registered, and Banchuk foresees a potential surge in fabricated prosecutions. A person who had not been found at their formal place of residence could be put on the wanted list and “summoned for questioning” in official publications they would be unlikely to read. They could, in short, end up being convicted without hearing of it.

Banchuk also calls the extended detention period a clear violation of the right to liberty, while the proposed amendments to Article 190, allowing for effectively indefinite arrest warrants, also breach the principle of legal precision. Who decides what constitutes “the particular complexity of the proceedings and existence of exceptional circumstances” that can be used to justify holding a person in detention for eighteen months? The bill is reverting to repressive features of the Soviet CPC and clearly breaches the constitutional prohibition on laws narrowing citizens’ rights.

Horbatyuk also believes that the draft bill needs major work. There must be a norm giving a person the right to judicial review, as long as they can prove that they did not know about the trial or had a proper reason for not attending. The bill also has other procedural infringements and a lack of legal clarity that would ultimately undermine convictions.

Destined for Strasbourg

There have been warnings from the outset that Ukraine’s leaders are risking the worst of all scenarios: a finding by the European Court of Human Rights that Yanukovych’s right to a fair trial has been violated.

The main reason is that the current bill and its predecessor are both openly aimed at putting Yanukovych on trial, laying Ukraine open to accusations of selective justice.

This is not simply an abstract fear. Poroshenko has stated that the bill is needed so that a court can establish Yanukovych’s guilt, and Yanukovych’s lawyer, Vitaly Serdyuk, has already said that that statement will be added to his team’s application to the Strasbourg Court “as proof of political persecution” of Yanukovych.

There are very serious grounds for bringing charges against Yanukovych and other high-ranking officials. Horbatyuk and his Special Investigations Department have been praised by lawyers and civic groups linked with the Euromaidan for their systematic approach and commitment to ensuring that the cases sent to the courts result in conviction. All of this, however, takes time.

There is real concern that the drive for a high-profile Yanukovych trial could result in a sloppy prosecution and conviction that could later be challenged. Vitaly Tytych, one of the lawyers representing the families of Maidan victims, has stressed that the families are not interested merely in pieces of paper. There need to be real verdicts passed by independent courts that are recognized internationally, with all the consequences that entails.

This is owed the victims, their families, and the Ukrainian people, and should not be sabotaged by politicians.
 



 

 

 

Recommend this post

comments

to post any message or commentary, you need to login »»

2017.04.06 | meadc

louis vuitton factory outlet


nike outlet


abercrombie outlet


michael kors outlet


ray-ban sunglasses


pandora princess ring


prada bags


coach factory outlet


burberry outlet


moncler jacket mens


Chanel Outlet


michael kors handbags


moncler down jackets


kate spade outlet online


yeezy boost 350 shoes


beats headphones


pandora rings


bercrombie Nederland


michael kors bags


canada goose sale online


Prada Factory Outlet


moncler uk


michael kors outlet


landinggear


Hugo Boss Online


veronique billat


authentic prada handbags outlet


abercrombie outlet us


michael kors tote


Michael Kors Outlet


michael kors outlet


kate spade bags outlet


major league baseball


michael kors bags


kate spade canada


louis vuitton outlet


Ralph Lauren


louis vuitton outlet


pandora charms


prada outlet online


baseball jerseys


burberry outlet canada


coach outlet


burberry online


louis vuitton outlet


pandora rings


michael kors outlet


abercrombie outlet


top sunglasses


yeezy boost 350


nike air huarache


Nike Hyperdunk Shoes


michael kors factory outlet


abercrombie and fitch


nike jordan shoes


burberry australia


pandora ring


abercrombie & fitch


burberry outlet


michael kors outlet


pandora rings


MIZUNO Shop US


coach outlet


nike shox shoes


canada goose outlet


pandora australia


Coach Outlet Store


ugg australia


pandora uk


abercrombie and fitch


mcm factory outlet


nike id


michael kors handbags outlet


Hyperdunk 2016


ray ban polarized


prada outlet


burberry outlet


prada outlet prices


coach sunglasses


pandora jewelry


coach usa


Kevin Durant Shoes


china factory sale


nike jordan shoes


ralph lauren


Oakley Holbrook sunglasses


ray ban eyeglasses


michael kors purses


coach bag


oakley frogskins


landing gear


huarache nike


prada factory outlet online


nike lebron shoes


sunglasses sm


michael kors uk


prada official site


Nike Jordans


mk bags


nike australia


adidas australia


coach online


pandora charms sale online


adidas australia


michael kors outlet


hockey jerseys


pandora rings


official michael kors


michael kors outlet


piumini moncler replica


prada outlet online


prada factory outlet online


polo online


prada sale


coach factory outlet


Michael Kors Canada


moncler us


kate spade outlet


michael kors purses


canada goose sale


oakley australia


michael kors totes


basketball jerseys


michael kors outlet


sunglasses hut


paul smith


pandora bracelet


oakley sunglasses


michael kors outlet


prada outlet


moncler outlet


nike jordan


clk benz


michael kors outlet


abercrombie and fitch


canada goose jacket


burberry outlet


pandora charms uk


michael kors outlet


prada bags outlet


Prada Outlet


cheap basketball shoes


coach outlet


pandora jewelry


landing gears


Mizuno Shoes


nike shox


prada outlet online


Pandora Charm


burberry scarf


coach outlet online


Free Run


Mizuno Wave


Burberry outlet online


coach carter


pandora charms


michael kors canada


basketball jerseys


michael kors tote


burberry purse


kate spade bags


prada outlet


Jordan Retro


burberry australia


shoes online


Nike Air Jordan


coach sunglasses for women


adidas shoes


michael kors wallet


ups tracking


pandora bracelet


nike huarache shoes


tiffany co


prada factory outlet


ralph lauren australia


shoes sale


pandora rings jewelry


kate spade black friday


kate spade outlet


prada purses


ugg australia


ray ban aviator


michael kors


Longchamp Outlet


abercrombie outlet


kate spade bags


Jordan Retro Shoes


mlb store


moncler clothing


prada bags on sale


burberry scarfs


lebron james shoes


mk outlet


pandora charms black friday


coach purses


moncler mens jackets


coach factory outlet online


prada bags


football jerseys


kate spade outlet


pandora rings


michael kors australia


pandora australia


Cheap Ray Ban


longchamp outlet


abercrombie paris


shoes online sale


abercrombie us


pandora necklace


coach handbags


coach diaper bag


adidas yeezy boost 350


coach outlet


pandora bracelet


prada outlet online


coach outlet


ray ban outlet


pandora charms sale clearance


nike jordan shoes


louis vuitton uk


coach outlet


canada goose jacket


prada handbags


nike com


pandora uk


michael kors purses outlet


abercrombie fitch


pandora charms


Billat


michael kors handbags


kate spade outlet


burberry scarf


Mizuno Shop Japan


coach outlet online


michael kors italy


coach outlet


prada outlet


oakley frogskins sunglasses


Nike KD 8


tiffany co


michael kors outlet


authentic prada outlet online


coach australia


moncler jacket


michael kors handbags


china wholesale


wholesale


Oakley Outlet


pandora necklaces


polo outlet


kate spade


timberland boots


ray ban wayfarer


Nike Jordan Shoes


louis vuitton australia


michael kors jet set tote


Canada Goose Outlet


michael kors outlet


pandora rings


michael kors


nike outlet


Hugo Boss Outlet


prada outlet


Ralph Lauren Polo


air jordan shoes


pandora necklace charms


chanel bag


michael kors purses on sale


burberry outlet online


michael kors uk


pandora charms


moncler outlet


michael kors bags outlet


prada factory outlet online


coach bags


ray-ban sunglasses


ray ban prescription glasses


coach outlet


louboutin shoes


abercrombie outlet


nike free run


pandora australia


Hugo Boss Store


nike shoes


Yeezy Boost 350


yeezy boost 350


coach outlet online


michael kors outlet bags


pandora rings sale


nike huarache


michael kors outlet


nike store


Coach Outlet


pandora jewelry


Abercrombie Fitch


ugg slippers


oakley sunglasses


coach outlet


kate spade


paul smith uk


pandora charms


prada outlet


mlb.com


prada bag


Nike Free


burberry canada


prada online


nike lebron james


coach outlet


polo outlet online


coach


authentic prada outlet online


prada glasses


air jordan shoes


moncler coats


michael kors outlet


coach outlet


prada bags


asics Australia


coach factory outlet


michael kors outlet


burberry outlet online


Mizuno Shop


michael kors outlet online


prada handbags


jimmy choo australia


ray ban sunglasses


huaraches


kate spade handbags


burberry outlet


coach australia


Jordan retro


moncler jacket


michael kors outlet


moncler sale


michael kors outlet


baseball jerseys


burberry canada


jordan retro shoes


Mizuno Running Shoes


chanel australia


Basketball shoes


ate spade handbags


cheap ray ban sunglasses


ray ban outlet


Prada bags


abercrombie outlet


michael kors outlet online


cheap moncler jacket


michael kors outlet


KD 8 shoes


pandora bracelets


official prada site


nfl shop


burberry online


Chanel bags Outlet


mk handbags


coach outlet


brand sunglasses


mcm outlet


burberry outlet


nike shoes australia


beats studio


pandora rings


cheap coach purse


chanel


kate spade black friday


prada handbags


nike basketball shoes


sunglasses hut


pandora charms sale


longchamp outlet


Hermes Outlet


Nike Air Max


pandora australia


burberry outlet canada


burberry


Coach Sunglasses Outlet


coach outlet store


salomon hiking shoes


ugg uk


prada outlet online


ray ban sunglasses


prada outlet online


coach purse


Pandora bracelet


beats by dre


pandora rings


mcm outlet online


Nike Air Jordan


nike shoes


CHanel Factory Outlet


huaraches shoes


burberry scarf


timberland uk


michael kors


oakley outlet


prada outlet online


michael kors outlet


official prada site


coach outlet


yeezy boost 350


ray ban prescription sunglasses


michael kors bags


football jerseys


michael kors outlet


oakley sunglasses


abercrombie us


Coach Outlet Online


ugg boots


kate spade


prada sunglasses


asics shoes Australia


Coach outlet online


coach handbags


ray ban new wayfarer


ray-ban sunglasses


michael kors


nike australia


véronique Billat


paul smith sale


jordan shoes


coach shoes


kate spade outlet online


moncler jacket


coach factory


nike air max


Ray Ban Outlet


michael kors us


Adidas Yeezy Boost 350


air jordan retro


pandora charms sale


michael kors outlet online


coach outlet online


ray ban glasses


kate spade outlet


asics shoes


moncler outlet


prada us


mlb shop


Kate Spade Australia


coach australia


Oakley Holbrook


michael kors outlet


ray ban online


mens sunglasses


flash sunglasses


coach bags


Nike Hyperdunk 2015


Michael Kors Outlet


coach factory outlet


rayban aviator


hermes bag


burberry us


baseball jerseys


pandora.com


michael kors outlet


kate spade outlet


coach outlet


prada outlet online


snow boots


michael kors online


mlb shop


michael kors black friday


louis vuitton outlet


salomon shoes


nfl jerseys


coach outlet


ray ban clubmaster


michael kors outlet


michael kors outlet


sunglasses outlet


Yeezy 350


ray ban sunglasses


ray ban sunglasses


pandora charms


me adc4.6

2017.04.08 | ypMs

botas de futbol


Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace


adidas outlet


Nike Shoes Sale Store


air force one pas cher


Nike Air Damen


ADIDAS NMD SALE ON LINE


cheap uggs for women


Cheap Toms Shoes Outlet


nike schuhe günstig


Soccer Boots Outlet nike


Pandora Official Website


louboutin heels


Yeezy Men


Jordan Sneakers For Sale


zapatillas nike baratas


Yeezy Boost Sale Online


Original Ugg Boots


cheap uggs


Nike Air Jordan 11


canada goose jackets on sale


Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher


Air Nike


Discount Air Max


Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel


pandora outlet store


ugg factory outlet


Nike Air Sneakers


Nike Shox discount Sale


Nike Soccer Cleats Boots


Canada Goose Womens Coats


religion store


nfl store


Jordan Shoes Air


zapatilla adidas


Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher


Nike Roshe Run Sale


Adidas Originals Superstar


hogan scontate


Nike Zapatos


official NHL jerseys


Cheap Toms Outlet Store


billige nike sko


Pandora Store


longchamp bags on sale


Ray Ban Sunglasses Online


Air Max Femme


pandora jewelry store


günstige nike schuhe


TOMS OUTLET


Pandora Store Sale


ugg clearance


nike air


Moncler Outlet Online


chaussure Nike homme


nike tn pas cher


nike mercurial soccer cleats


Adidas Superstar Sale Online


Pandora Store


Timberland Outlet


ugg store


Cheap Michael Kors


vans shoe store


scarpe nike


Nike Air 90


Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher


nike sneakers


Moncler Outlet Store


abercrombie and fitch store


retro jordans for cheap


Nike Air Max Cheap


zapatos de futbol nike


nike joggesko


Uggs Pas Cher Soldes


Descuentos Nike


Kobe Shoes Nike


Canada Goose Outlet


prada outlet


coach factory outlet online


converse store


Adidas Originals Stan Smith


Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace


Nike Air Women


uggs outlet


nike sportschuhe


Boty Nike Air


Nike Online Store


Boost Yeezy Sale On Line


christian louboutin outlet


zapatillas running


Nike Pas Cher Femme


Yeezy Black


Nike Shox Cheap


Air Max Pas Cher


Michael Kors Outlet


Oakley Sunglasses Cheap


adidas store


Michael Kors


Stone Island Outlet


Jordan Store


new jordan releases


Adidas Neo Discount Sale


Uggs For Cheap


huarache sneakers


reebok running shoes


TOMS SHOES OUTLET


Michael Kors Handbags Discount


Air Max Kopen


Ugg Pas Cher Femme


new pandora charms


Ugg boots Sale


Air max dam


suivre un envoi


womens nike air max


Discount TOMS


nike air max running shoes


Ugg Outlet Online Store


Cheap Air Max Trainers


UGG BOOTS FOR WOMEN


Ray ban sale online


new yeezy shoes


23 IS BACK Store


Ugg Pas Cher En France


scarpe hogan outlet


nike sb stefan janoski


Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher


Canada Goose Outlet


Vans Black Sneakers


nike air jordan pas cher


Hogan Outlet


Nike Air Pas Cher


fitflops sale uk


chaussures nike pas cher


Toms Factory Outlet


Air Max 90


nike shoes


Nike Air Max Goedkoop


Toms Outlet Online


Negozi Pandora


pandora beads


Canada goose dam


Coach Bags On Sale


goedkope nike air max


Adidas Superstar


Scarpe Air Max


Official Toms Shoes Outlet


Nike Store


Air Max Sneakers


toms sale


moncler jacket sale


Yeezy Shoes Discount Marketplace


Air max levně


Air Jordan Retro Sale


Hugo Boss Sale


Jordan Schoenen


canada goose jacket outlet


chaussure basket homme


Nike Factory Store


nike jordan shoes


Moncler Sale


Boutique Ugg


TOMS For Sale


Nike Air Huarache For Sale


Cheap Michael Kors Tote Bag


cheap nike air max


Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace


toms shoes outlet


Ray-Ban Official Discounted Site


newest lebron shoes



ypMs 2017.4.8

X




forgot the password

registration

X

X

send me a new password


on top