search  
print
06.03.2017 | Halya Coynash

Blogger fined for saying the USSR invaded Poland in 1939 takes Russia to Court in Strasbourg

Hitler & Stalin over Poland.png
   

Russian blogger Vladimir Luzgin has asked the European Court of Human Rights to defend his right to state quite correctly that both Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union invaded Poland in 1939.  He was left no alternative after Russia’s Supreme Court agreed that this unpalatable truth constituted ‘rehabilitation of Nazism’. Luzgin is the first person in Russia to have been convicted under a controversial law which was, from the outset, condemned as an attack on historical debate.  It has proven to be an offensive against historical facts.

The 37-year-old from Perm in Siberia was convicted on June 30, 2016 and fined 200 thousand roubles for reposting an article on his social network page entitled ‘15 facts about Bandera supporters, or what the Kremlin is silent about’.  The Ukrainian theme, especially with respect to the Ukrainian nationalist leader Stepan Bandera, would have almost certainly attracted FSB [Russian security service] attention to Luzgin back in September 2015, however the criminal charges were brought over the following lines:

“The communists and Germany jointly invaded Poland, sparking off the Second World War.  That is, communism and Nazism closely collaborated…”

The first court considered this to be “knowingly false information”, claiming as justification that the statement contradicted the facts set out in the Nuremberg Tribunal sentences.  That verdict was upheld by Russia’s Supreme Court on September 16, 2016, the 77th anniversary of Nazi Germany’s s invasion of Poland, 17 days before the anniversary of the Soviet invasion from the east. 

Under Russian President Vladimir Putin, Moscow has consistently denied such undeniable facts as its invasion of Crimea and military involvement in Eastern Ukraine.  It unfortunately even finds people willing to accept the Kremlin’s narrative on such subjects.

Here the situation is radically different.  You will not find any reputable historian or source denying that the Soviet Union invaded Poland.  Even Putin has only tried to defend the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, whose secret protocol carved up Poland, not to claim that there was no such agreement.   

This has not prevented a shifting of focus in Russia which certainly distorts the facts.  There was outrage in Poland in September 2015 when first Russia’s ambassador to Venezuela, then its ambassador to Poland both tried to claim that it was Poland that had provoked WWII, not the Soviet Union. 

The Law on ‘Rehabilitation of Nazism’, officially authored by Iryna Yarovaya, was signed into force on May 5, 2014. The new Article 354.1 of the criminal code it introduces carries a sentence of up to 3 years imprisonment for what is termed ‘public denial or approval of the facts established by the sentence of the Nuremberg Tribunal’.  The same norm makes it possible to prosecute somebody for “spreading knowingly false information about the activities of the USSR during the years of the Second World War”.  There is no guidance as to how something is determined to be false.  This is how Luzgin came to be fined for telling the truth.

The law was condemned by the Sova Centre as aimed at stifling historical discussion and restricting freedom of speech.

Kommersant reports that Luzgin has appealed to the Court in Strasbourg, asserting infringement of his right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the European Convention.  Violation is also alleged of Article 7 of the Convention, guaranteeing punishment solely on the basis of law. 

The applicant notes that he never denied the criminal nature of the Nazi regime, and that a text stating that certain events took place can in no way be viewed as denial of Nazi crimes. 

Luzgin is represented by Kirill Koroteev, Legal Director of the renowned Memorial Society.  It must be possible to foresee what actions will be prohibited under Article 354.1 of the criminal code, yet this, the applicant asserts, is not the case.  Two courts have chosen to view an assertion about undeniable facts from WWII which the Nuremberg Tribunal did not itself mention as being false information. 

There are plenty of crimes which were not mentioned by the Nuremberg Tribunal, such as the Katyń Massacre of over 20 thousand Polish officers.  They did happen.

It seems likely that the lack of clarity and, therefore, foreseeability is quite intentional.  The original bill was tabled shortly after TV Dozhd came under massive attack and threat of being closed for a public survey in which Russians were asked whether the Siege of Leningrad had been worth the loss of life.  During the discussion in the State Duma on the bill, deputies directly linked its adoption with, among other things, Russia’s annexation of Crimea. 

Another, equally cynical, amendment to the criminal code in May 2014, Article 280.1 has already been used to imprison Russians and is now being applied against Ukrainians in occupied Crimea for saying that Crimea is Ukrainian and that Russia’s occupation should end. 

Luzgin’s surreal conviction was doubtless intended as a chilling warning of what to expect if you raise questions the current regime does not want asked, or facts it wants blurred or downright denied. . 

It is very likely that the ongoing detention on absurd charges of historian and Memorial activist Yury Dmitriev is also intended as a warning to others not to expose information about the perpetrators of Stalin’s Terror.

 

Recommend this post

comments

to post any message or commentary, you need to login »»

2017.03.10 | hyhMs

Nike Air Women


Boost Yeezy Sale On Line


Air Max Kopen


ugg clearance


TOMS SHOES OUTLET


Cheap Michael Kors


cheap nike air max


cheap uggs


Nike Air 90


Pandora Store


uggs for women


Air Max Pas Cher


scarpe nike


Kobe Shoes Nike


christian louboutin outlet


nike sportschuhe


zapatillas running


Hugo Boss Sale


Ray ban sale online


Descuentos Nike


nfl store


nike air


zapatilla adidas


Yeezy Men


nike air max running shoes


Scarpe Air Max


zapatillas nike baratas


toms sale


nike shoes


huarache sneakers


nike joggesko


Nike Factory Store


Adidas Originals Superstar


Air Nike


moncler outlet


Nike Air Jordan 11


pandora outlet store


Jordan Store


prada outlet


Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace


retro jordans for cheap


air force one pas cher


Nike Shox discount Sale


Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher


Ugg Pas Cher En France


günstige nike schuhe


ugg factory outlet


Jordan Shoes Air


The official UGG


adidas store


Hogan Outlet


Pandora Store


Canada Goose Outlet


billige nike sko


Ugg boots Sale


nike jordan shoes


Air Max 90


moncler jacket sale


womens nike air max


newest lebron shoes


Coach Bags On Sale


toms shoes outlet


uggs outlet


Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel


pandora beads


chaussure Nike homme


Air Max Sneakers


Yeezy Black


Nike Online Store


Adidas Originals Stan Smith


converse store


Boutique Ugg


Nike Shoes Sale Store


new jordan releases


canada goose jackets on sale


Vans Black Sneakers


Nike Air Damen


Jordan Sneakers For Sale


nike mercurial soccer cleats


Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace


Ray Ban Sunglasses Online


religion store


Michael Kors Outlet


vans shoe store


Air Max Femme


Michael Kors


nike sneakers


canada goose jacket outlet


ugg store


Canada Goose Womens Coats


hogan scontate


Nike Air Max Cheap


Nike Air Huarache For Sale


Yeezy Boost Sale Online


new yeezy shoes


Discount Air Max


Canada Goose Outlet


Canada goose dam


nike air jordan pas cher


Ugg Outlet Online Store


official NHL jerseys


Jordan Schoenen


Moncler Sale


Timberland Outlet


reebok running shoes


nike sb stefan janoski


Nike Air Sneakers


Nike Pas Cher Femme


Adidas Superstar


Adidas Neo Discount Sale


Uggs Pas Cher Soldes


cheap uggs for women


Nike Shox Cheap


Nike Store


Ugg Pas Cher Femme


Nike Zapatos


Adidas Superstar Sale Online


pandora jewelry store


ADIDAS NMD SALE ON LINE


new pandora charms


botas de futbol


Michael Kors Handbags Discount


Air Jordan Retro Sale


goedkope nike air max


Toms Outlet Online


nike tn pas cher


Oakley Sunglasses Cheap


Boty Nike Air


Pandora Official Website


Nike Roshe Run Sale


Uggs For Cheap


Negozi Pandora


Air max levně


longchamp bags on sale


zapatos de futbol nike


coach factory outlet online


Moncler Outlet Store


Moncler Outlet Online


Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher


Ray-Ban Official Discounted Site


louboutin heels


Nike Soccer Cleats Boots


Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher


fitflops sale uk


Stone Island Outlet


Soccer Boots Outlet nike


Nike Air Max Goedkoop


chaussures nike pas cher


adidas outlet


chaussure basket homme


Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace


scarpe hogan outlet


Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher


abercrombie and fitch store


Original Ugg Boots


Air max dam


nike schuhe günstig



hyhMs 2017.3.10

X




forgot the password

registration

X

X

send me a new password


on top