31.03.2017 | Halya Coynash

Arrest warrant on ex-Ukrainian PM culminates Russia’s most cynical torture-based political trial

Yatsenyuk, Klykh (left) and Karpyuk in court.png

A Russian court has issued an ‘arrest warrant’ on ex-Ukrainian Prime Minister Arseny Yatsenyuk, claiming that he was placed on the international wanted list on Feb 21, 2017.  There is no evidence that Interpol knows it is supposed to be looking for Yatsenyuk, and every reason to assume they would refuse to do so.  The charges are almost certainly based on ‘confessions’ tortured out of two Ukrainians whom Russia was holding totally incommunicado and retracted as soon as Stanislav Klykh and Mykola Karpyuk were finally given access to real lawyers.  It is not only the men’s word on this, since the authoritative Memorial Human Rights Centre demolished the charges which clash irreconcilably with proven historical facts. 

The Yesentuki City Court reported on March 27 that it was issuing the arrest warrant in absentia on the basis of an application from a Russian Investigative Committee investigator “on particular important cases’.  The charges are identical to those brought against Klykh and Karpyuk over supposed involvement in the fighting in Chechnya against Russian federal forces in late 1994 and early 1995. They include: taking part in a gang and its attacks; the murder of two or more people in connection with their carrying of official duty, and attempts to commit such murder (multiple parts of Articles 209 and 102 of the Russian criminal code, and 102 of the Russian SSR criminal code).   

The first public claim that the then Prime Minister Yatsenyuk had fought in Chechnya came in September 2015 in an interview given by the head of the Investigative Committee Alexander Bastrykin.  The latter treated the involvement of Yatsenyuk and other prominent Ukrainians as established fact and claimed that Yatsenyuk had tortured and murdered Russian soldiers.  No convincing evidence was provided for the extraordinary allegations and Internet users reacted with wild mirth and a flood of hilarious photoshop images of Yatsenyuk as Chechen fighter. 

The reality was anything but amusing since Klykh had given his ‘confessions’ after being seized from a hotel, then held for 10 months incommunicado, and subjected to terrible torture.  Karpyuk’s experiences was similar except that he was secretly held for over a year and a half.

A third Ukrainian’s testimony is generally also cited.  Olexander Malofeyev was sentenced in October 2010 to 24.5 years’ maximum security for his supposed part in the fighting in Chechnya.  Malofeyev had long lived in Russia, where he was already serving a 23-year sentence. He is also a drug addict with several life-threatening illnesses meaning that pressure could easily be exerted by taking away his medication. 

Memorial HRC and Ukrainian activists have found major inaccuracies regarding Malofeyev’s account of historical details, and he can in no way be considered a reliable source.  It is likely that the stunt with his ‘trial’ on the allegedly ‘newly exposed information’ was attempted purely as a prelude to the trial about to begin in Chechnya of Karpyuk and Klykh. 

Evidence was provided during the trial proving Klykh had been taking exams at university in Kyiv during the period when he was supposed to be running around Chechnya killing soldiers, while Karpyuk had been looking after his dying mother. 

A leading Memorial figure spoke during the court trial in the men’s favour, and an extensive Memorial analysis in 4 parts was carried out. This pointed to major factual mistakes and to the fact that some of the lurid confessions were to heinous crimes which simply never happened.  The prosecution had left the confessions in the indictment, but not charged the men.  Memorial suggested that this was so that monstrous details of non-existent crimes would have an emotional impact on the jury which the defence would be powerless to fight. 

The factual mistakes were enormously significant.  Of the 30 soldiers whom Russia claimed had been killed by Karpyuk and Klykh, 18 had died in another place altogether, and a further eleven were not killed by gunfire, as the prosecution claimed.   One man had died of gunfire, but not from the type of gun that the investigators claimed was used.

There was no historical evidence to back the tales of torture and extrajudicial executions presented by the prosecution.  The investigators had not provided any information as to bodies found with marks of torture, or of the identity of the victims. 

On these grounds and others, Memorial HRC in February 2016 declared both Klykh and Karpyuk political prisoners.  There seems to have been considerable pressure brought to bear on jury members who ignored all evidence that the men had never set foot in Chechnya, that their ‘confessions’ had been extracted through torture and hat the alleged crimes had not happened.

In May 2016, Karpyuk was sentenced to 22.5 years, Klykh to 20.  Serious grounds for concern about Klykh’s mental state have been ignored, and both men are now in maximum security prisons. 

Both men were effectively abducted from within Russia’s borders.  Yatsenyuk faces no such danger, and reacted back in September 2015 with dismissive comments about the sanity of those presenting such delirious charges.  Since two men have now received huge sentences for this same nonsense, the cynical lies need to be fought, not merely dismissed.  


Recommend this post


to post any message or commentary, you need to login »»

2017.04.08 | ypMs

botas de futbol

Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace

adidas outlet

Nike Shoes Sale Store

air force one pas cher

Nike Air Damen


cheap uggs for women

Cheap Toms Shoes Outlet

nike schuhe günstig

Soccer Boots Outlet nike

Pandora Official Website

louboutin heels

Yeezy Men

Jordan Sneakers For Sale

zapatillas nike baratas

Yeezy Boost Sale Online

Original Ugg Boots

cheap uggs

Nike Air Jordan 11

canada goose jackets on sale

Bottes Ugg Femme Pas Cher

Air Nike

Discount Air Max

Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel

pandora outlet store

ugg factory outlet

Nike Air Sneakers

Nike Shox discount Sale

Nike Soccer Cleats Boots

Canada Goose Womens Coats

religion store

nfl store

Jordan Shoes Air

zapatilla adidas

Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher

Nike Roshe Run Sale

Adidas Originals Superstar

hogan scontate

Nike Zapatos

official NHL jerseys

Cheap Toms Outlet Store

billige nike sko

Pandora Store

longchamp bags on sale

Ray Ban Sunglasses Online

Air Max Femme

pandora jewelry store

günstige nike schuhe


Pandora Store Sale

ugg clearance

nike air

Moncler Outlet Online

chaussure Nike homme

nike tn pas cher

nike mercurial soccer cleats

Adidas Superstar Sale Online

Pandora Store

Timberland Outlet

ugg store

Cheap Michael Kors

vans shoe store

scarpe nike

Nike Air 90

Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher

nike sneakers

Moncler Outlet Store

abercrombie and fitch store

retro jordans for cheap

Nike Air Max Cheap

zapatos de futbol nike

nike joggesko

Uggs Pas Cher Soldes

Descuentos Nike

Kobe Shoes Nike

Canada Goose Outlet

prada outlet

coach factory outlet online

converse store

Adidas Originals Stan Smith

Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace

Nike Air Women

uggs outlet

nike sportschuhe

Boty Nike Air

Nike Online Store

Boost Yeezy Sale On Line

christian louboutin outlet

zapatillas running

Nike Pas Cher Femme

Yeezy Black

Nike Shox Cheap

Air Max Pas Cher

Michael Kors Outlet

Oakley Sunglasses Cheap

adidas store

Michael Kors

Stone Island Outlet

Jordan Store

new jordan releases

Adidas Neo Discount Sale

Uggs For Cheap

huarache sneakers

reebok running shoes


Michael Kors Handbags Discount

Air Max Kopen

Ugg Pas Cher Femme

new pandora charms

Ugg boots Sale

Air max dam

suivre un envoi

womens nike air max

Discount TOMS

nike air max running shoes

Ugg Outlet Online Store

Cheap Air Max Trainers


Ray ban sale online

new yeezy shoes

23 IS BACK Store

Ugg Pas Cher En France

scarpe hogan outlet

nike sb stefan janoski

Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher

Canada Goose Outlet

Vans Black Sneakers

nike air jordan pas cher

Hogan Outlet

Nike Air Pas Cher

fitflops sale uk

chaussures nike pas cher

Toms Factory Outlet

Air Max 90

nike shoes

Nike Air Max Goedkoop

Toms Outlet Online

Negozi Pandora

pandora beads

Canada goose dam

Coach Bags On Sale

goedkope nike air max

Adidas Superstar

Scarpe Air Max

Official Toms Shoes Outlet

Nike Store

Air Max Sneakers

toms sale

moncler jacket sale

Yeezy Shoes Discount Marketplace

Air max levně

Air Jordan Retro Sale

Hugo Boss Sale

Jordan Schoenen

canada goose jacket outlet

chaussure basket homme

Nike Factory Store

nike jordan shoes

Moncler Sale

Boutique Ugg

TOMS For Sale

Nike Air Huarache For Sale

Cheap Michael Kors Tote Bag

cheap nike air max

Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace

toms shoes outlet

Ray-Ban Official Discounted Site

newest lebron shoes

ypMs 2017.4.8


forgot the password




send me a new password

on top