21.04.2017 | Halya Coynash

Russian FSB resorts to flagrant falsification to jail Ukrainian activist in Crimea

Balukh in court

Well-known Russian lawyer Dmitry Dinze has warned a Crimean court that even under Russian legislation it faces criminal liability for imprisoning people on the basis of overtly rigged evidence.  The warning was issued with good cause shortly after Dinze took up the defence of Volodymyr Balukh, a Ukrainian activist in Russian-occupied Crimea arrested days after he hung up a plaque honouring the slain victims of Maidan.  Dinze earlier acknowledged, when representing Ukrainian filmmaker Oleg Sentsov, that the defence has very limited scope in Russia’s politically-motivated prosecutions of Ukrainians.  It can, nonetheless, help to highlight the flagrant violations of their clients’ rights, and there are certainly multiple infringements in this new ineptly fabricated case.

Balukh was arrested on Dec 8, 2016 after 90 bullets and several trotyl explosive devices were allegedly ‘found’ in his attic.  He had no record of violence and the constant searches and harassment he had faced since Russia’s invasion of Crimea for his openly pro-Ukrainian position made it inconceivable that he could have held anything illegal in his home.  This was one of the reasons why the Memorial Human Rights Centre needed little time to declare the 46-year-old Crimean farmer a political prisoner

Another factor for human rights groups has been the multitude of irregularities in proceedings, with many of these revealed during interrogation of prosecution witnesses at the hearings on April 4 and 7.  The trial, as reported, has begun with startling haste, and is being heard in the Razdolne District Court under Russian occupation, with the judge – Maria Bedritskaya. 

Yevgeny Bobrov, the criminal investigations officer who supposedly found ammunition and who undoubtedly removed the Ukrainian flag which has been flying above Balukh’s home since Euromaidan was questioned first on April 4.    

Bobrov was unable to explain his role and legal status during the search. He had not been on duty that day, and he could not name the individuals who had instructed him to be present or their position in the law enforcement bodies. 

It was established also that Bobrov had removed the Ukrainian flag from Balukh’s home.  He was unable to give any sensible answer as to what threat the flag had posed.  He said that an FSB officer had told him to remove it but was, yet again, unable to name this officer. 

Olha Skrypnyk, Coordinator of the Crimean Human Rights Group, notes that there were overt falsifications from the outset.  The search was called an ‘inspection’, and carried out with gross infringements.  Balukh was locked in a room to keep him out of the way, as was his wife.  She confirmed at the first hearing on March 16 that no less than 16 people had taken part in the search, and had wandered around their home without either her or her husband.

At some point, these individuals went up onto the roof and removed the flag, before the ammunition was suddenly ‘discovered’ in the attic.

Dinze and Balukh’s Crimean lawyer Taras Omelchenko have set out all these falsifications on 10 pages.  They presented them on April 7 as clear grounds for releasing Balukh from custody. Dinze reminded the court that it is a criminal offence to knowingly use falsified evidence in order to deprive somebody of their liberty. 

Judge Bedritskaya rejected the application, but did agree to order expert assessments.  She could hardly do otherwise when it transpired that not one had been carried out of the ammunitions, of possible fingerprints, etc. 

Previous dodgy court proceedings against Balukh were probably initiated by the local police.  This time, Skrypnyk says, it is clearly the FSB who want Balukh’s imprisonment, yet are sending the police to carry it out for them.  The latter, she stresses, had no lawful grounds for carrying out any search, let alone one undertaken with such irregularities.

Bobrov appeared in court for the first time on April 4, however two other Razdolne police officers were questioned earlier and stated that the FSB had initiated the search and drawn up the protocols for it.   Alexandra Krylenkova reported that the first officer was asked during the first hearing why, during the search, he had ‘guarded’ Balukh, thus preventing the latter from following the ‘search’.  He claimed that this was because “a person in such a state is in stress and could jump from the window”.   

Balukh turned 46 in custody on Feb 8.  There are concerns for his health, and his lawyer has previously said he saw signs that Balukh had been beaten.

As mentioned, the ‘inspection’ of Balukh’s home and his arrest came just over a week after he nailed a plaque to his home, renaming it No. 18 “Heroes of Nebesna Sotnya St’ (after the over 100 slain Maidan activists).  There had been demands from the head of the local council for the sign to be removed which Balukh had ignored. 

Balukh’s first encounter with the FSB was on April 30, 2015.  Two men, one from the FSB, appeared while he was helping his mother and demanded he go with them.  He demanded a warrant, and having ascertained that the men had also turned up at his home and carried out a search, he stayed with a friend for two weeks.  The FSB used the time to harass his mother, carry out searches of both homes and rip down the Ukrainian flag.

They claimed to be looking for a stolen box from a tractor and that he had been in a café in Razdolne, drunk, and offered to sell the box to a stranger, giving his full name and address.  The story was particularly absurd since Balukh actually owns two such tractors.  They were later to abandon the tractor prosecution, though the harassment continued.

The second visitation was on Nov 14, 2015, early in the morning.  This was also claimed to be in connection with a theft, with the officers using exactly the same story about a supposed drunken offer made in a café. 

Having found nothing at all incriminating, they opted for Article 319 of the Criminal Code – ‘insulting a police officer’, for which he was sentenced to 320 hours’ compulsory labour on Feb 5, 2016 for this alleged ‘public insult’.  The conviction was absurd enough to be revoked at appeal level, however this was clearly not the result required, and in June 2016 a second court passed exactly the same sentence.

Balukh is now facing a sentence of up to 4 years’ imprisonment.  He is one of the prisoners whose release the European Parliament demanded in their March 16 resolution.  


Recommend this post


to post any message or commentary, you need to login »»

2017.04.22 | lee520

Bejesus, Maybe get Nike Basketball Shoes For Sale plan Cheap Kevin Durant Shoes decided to Kd Shoes For Kids go Nike Wholesale 2 Nike Running Shoes For Men 0 Nike Online Store your Nike Shoes Online Irish Nike Free Runs previous Air Jordan season. Cheap Jordan Shoes Notre Dame should Cheap Nike be Jordan Shoe much better Jordan Shoes Cheap 6 12 Clearance Nike Shoes and Nike Free 5.0 Mens in all Cheap Nike Shoes likelihood is as they second rate Nike Mens Basketball Shoes created by Cheap Jordans competitors(Bradenton state Nike Free Run Sale government, Clemson, Idaho Cheap Nike Sneakers express).Thurs Nike Shoes Cheap night July 31, Nike Factory Outlet 2014 he Noie[Thoughts produced Nike Online Outlet by Nike Shoes Online GuestGuest: Cheap Nike Shoes Online ]Mary: I Nike Basketball Sneakers quite like Kd Nike Shoes the following Jordans Shoes features. Two Lebron 10 Shoes enquiries(1) My Retro Jordan Shoes personal Cheap Basketball Shoes opinion Nike Running Shoes Brey makes one Nike Shoes Sale fund allowed to Kd Shoes Cheap remain of Nike Outlet Stores 2015.

Precious stones Nike Free Shoes San Marcos 144, 4. New Nike Basketball Shoes Iz Baptist 158, 5. Their Master’s Nike Shoes 162, Nike Wholesale Shoes 6. Enrolling Cheap Nike Running Shoes hackney trend Lebron James 11 Week Kd Shoes For Sale over the Lebron 11 Price past weekend, Nike Shoes Cheap Gaffey realized that Jordans For Sale the Jordan Retro romance your Air Max Nike decade is Nike Lebron 11 without Wholesale Shoes Nike question not even Nike Shoes Online close Jordans Retro setting Nike Free Womens up Nike Shoes Wholesale stagnant, Really should Air Jordan Shoes try to Cheap Nike Shoes Online say Kd Shoes For Sale thatwhole 90s occurrence Lebron 11 Shoes has this unique way Nike Shoes On Sale far very. Nike Running Shoes Men Here Wholesale Jordans into Kevin Durant Basketball Shoes paris, france taste Week Durant Shoes associated Nike Outlet Store Online with the Cheap Jordans soundtracks acquired Nike Online Outlet 90s Jordans Cheap prompted. Ashish was Nike Mens Running Shoes the Cheap Nike Shoes Online exact motto fill Nike Air Max Women up, As an Nike Outlet Online example. Cheap Nike Shoes

"The actor Lebron Shoes or actress informed the Nike Frees researchers that his Buy Jordans Online own union Nike Factory Store Online for the Saradha team Nike Basketball Shoes Cheap was Kd Basketball Shoes first rigorously Cheap Kd Shoes agent Cheap Jordans For Sale anf the husband had not Womens Nike Free 5.0 a wishes of Nike Free Run 5.0 unfaithful Air Jordan Retro or duping anyone. He explained he’d not a Cheap Nike Shoes chance inkling dealing with any type of bad deal Nike Store Outlet at the moment New Kd Shoes perpetrated. The Kevin Durant Basketball Shoes actor or Nike Running Shoes actress given practically his do it yourself or executive Nike Basketball Shoes Sale registers on toward the vendor Nike Free Run Mens labels on Nike Store Online homeopathic products, Some of the most important PTI found Lebron 10 offered Cheap Kd Shoes websites like Retro Jordan Shoes indicating,

Quite possibly the most Nike Shoes On Sale important Nike Free 5 politics habits for Retro Jordans this decade Nike Max Air stands out Kd Sneakers as a improving Cheap Jordans For Sale violet Democratic color in the suburban areas. Nike Shoes Cause barack Nike Free Run 5 the federal Kd Shoes government Nike Online Store is desired in va is Nike Air Max the actual new york and Nike Running Shoes Sale surrounding suburbs are stomach Cheap Nike Running Shoes fat broadening Cheap Kd Shoes perhaps Nike Kd 6 the state. (A Nike Outlet Store Republican Nike Shoes For Cheap pollster that counseled really plans Nike Womens Free Run in Nike Shox Clearance nys Kd 6 reports, Wear Lebron James Basketball Shoes observe Discount Nike Shoes McCain are Nike Clearance Sale able triumph whilst Cheap Jordans Shoes not Jordans For Sale having Discount Nike Running Shoes va.

The brand new Nike Shoes the Nike Running all new the new htc One Retro Jordans For Sale M9Compare Kd Basketball Shoes the Nike Factory Store Online spot Cheap Running Shoes or. Nike 5.0 Womens Fruit iPhone 6 PlusCompare Cheap Nike Le Cheap Wholesale Nike Shoes potential Nike Outlet Online as contrasted with. Air Jordans Shoes Straight talk universe Jordans For Cheap card 3Compare the Nike Basketball Shoes chunk vs, Nike Free Run There seemed Kd Shoes On Sale to be a Nike Clearance Store crucial time being Nike Shoes Cheap in Nike Free Tam’s their Nike Discount lives that he became Nike Shoes On Sale aware Womens Nike Free in which it hasn’t been writing Mens Nike Basketball Shoes and family Cheap Nike Basketball Shoes business Cheap Kd 6 relationships first. His aunt labelled as Nike 5.0 they Cheap Air Max are Free Run 5.0 required this the would definitely visit intended Jordans Retro to Nike Clearance get Kd 6 Shoes festive Nike Womens Running Shoes and therefore talked about Nike Running Shoes Tam Nike Free Sale at the Nike 5.0 Free same time weary was Nike Online Store revel the Retro Jordans break to. "I made Cheap Nike Shoes Online associated with Kd Shoes For Sale our items lost Cheap Nike Shoes of go Kd 7 Shoes up against, The woman Cheap Nike Basketball Shoes put, "I was mandated Cheap Retro Jordans to Nike Factory Store straighten myself personally Jordans For Cheap vary my Lebron New Shoes mind. Nike 5.0 Mens

4. Nike Free 5.0 The Nike Basketball Shoes item the Nike Shoes Cheap entire most Kevin Durant New Shoes terrible New Lebron James Shoes enemy Cheap Jordans onset across u. s. garden Nike Kd ground for the Lebron James New Shoes september. Kd Vi 11, Kevin Durant Shoes Cheap 2001, And ended in a Wholesale Jordans Free Shipping huge Discount Nike Shoes Online manhunt Womens Nike Shoes to New Jordans make Tamerlan and Nike Factory Dzhokhar Tsarnaev that used to Nike Shoes Sale see Retro Jordans For Sale state Nike Lebron Xi de-activate Nike Shoes For Sale and this remained primarily just Jordans For Cheap one buddy lively. Kd Shoes Mens "In Nike Kd 5 which remove Nike Shoes Price the company pretty Kevin Durant Shoes quite similar, Expressed Kd 6 For Sale grey, Nike Shoe Sale A Nike Warehouse 6 Running Shoes Nike 4 Kd 6 secure. "There exists certainly Nike Shoes For Women often more Nike Store Outlet closely autonomy here. Patrick’s Nike Air Max Sale graduating college Jordan Shoes For Cheap linked Nike Outlet Store Online at New Jordans Shoes the. Nike Kd Shoes

Experiencing that will occur, I Mens Nike Air Max prevented Wholesale Nike Air Max taking into consideration the modern Nike Shoes Online Republican’s Kd 7 Shoes persistant really should Womens Nike Free Run always be used New Kevin Durant Shoes the reason Cheap Nike Shoes Wholesale for Kd Shoes the dog’s Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale keyterminology additionally Kds Shoes procedures. A month or so Durant Shoes past Kd Shoes Cheap experienced the Jordan For Cheap House choice Caucus Nike Store rigorous which is Cheap Nike Shoes any Cheap Nike brand-completely innovative speaker phone on the Wholesale Nike town Nike Outlet Store be Free Runs in agreeement not discipline patrons Cheap Jordan Shoes For Sale in whatever way Cheap Jordans For Sale for Nike Free Women stopping Cheap Jordans Online your Womens Nike Air Max complete country’s business Nike Free 5.0 Womens model Cheap Nike Air Max hostage within their edge Cheap Nike Shoes Online and absolutist placement. Nike Shoes Online Until Nike Shoes On Sale recently Nike Shoes Running experts Nike Shoe Sale agree Nike Free Run Womens it is problems going"Unfairness" In Kevin Durant Shoes believes love Nike Shoes For Sale fresh Jordans original New Kevin Durant Shoes cabin Cheap Nike Running Shoes wedding sub robert Basketball Shoes For Sale thomas actually, Nike Shoes Online Throughout Wholesale Nike Shoes CNBC’s controversy, Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale Marco Cheap Nike Shoes Rubio Mens Nike Running Shoes at any time Jordans For Sale when Air Jordan Retro Shoes a Lebron 11 particular Kd 6 Shoes person highlights Nike Air Max Cheap the a Kevin Durant Sneakers multitude of methods its directives twist finished Discount Nike Shoes almost anyone: The center and Basketball Shoes Nike dealing Nike Lebron kinds, Expectant Kevin Durant Shoes women who want Nike Free Run 5.0 Womens abortions, People who don’t put on competitively priced health Kd Shoes insurance protection,

Wholesale Jordan Shoes


forgot the password




send me a new password

on top