Russian censor prohibits Crimea Human Rights Group from informing Crimeans of their rights
Russia as occupying state is not only violating international law by conscripting Crimeans into its army, but has placed material from the Crimean Human Rights Group informing people of this on its huge ‘Register of prohibited information’. It has threatened that if the material is not removed, the Group’s webpage will be blocked.
Roskomnadzor, Russia’ effective censor, sent notification on 10 May of the ban on three texts and demanding that the owner of the site used by the Crimean Human Rights Group be informed of the need to remove the material within 24 hours. The ban was formally sanctioned by Antonina Lantratova, ‘judge’ of the Russian-controlled Yevpatoria City Court on 21 March this year. Unsurprisingly, the text of the ‘court rulings’ is not posted on the court’s website.
The three articles (posted in Russian) are:
The human rights activists are not so easily intimidated and call this latest move a flagrant violation of freedom of expression. Russia is trying to prevent Crimeans receiving proper information about their illegal use of conscription.
Russia’s attempts to deny that it is occupying Crimea have been rejected by the United Nations General Assembly, as well as by all international bodies and democratic states. The International Criminal Court at the Hague’s Chief Prosecutor concluded back in 2016 that Russia’s occupation constitutes an international armed conflict, placing it within the Court’s jurisdiction which Ukraine has recognized.
Russia is a party to numerous international documents which set restrictions on what an occupying power may do. According to Article 51 of the Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, “The Occupying Power may not compel protected persons to serve in its armed or auxiliary forces. No pressure or propaganda which aims at securing voluntary enlistment is permitted”.
Conscription is a major concern for many young men and their parents, and there have also been complaints that some of them have been placed under pressure to renounce their Ukrainian citizenship. Oleksandr Sedov from the Crimean Human Rights Group is blunt about such attempts which he calls a war crime. The 1907 Hague Convention states unequivocally that “it is forbidden to compel the inhabitants of occupied territory to swear allegiance to the hostile Power.”
The list of rights violations in occupied Crimea is huge and includes persecution on the grounds of a person’s faith. Following Russia’s ban on the Jehovah’s Witnesses in April 2017, there have already been a number of arrests of individual believers. In Crimea, at least two Jehovah’s Witnesses have been ordered to provide ‘proof of change of faith’ in order to be eligible for alternative civilian service.
According to the Russian legislation illegally applied in Crimea, all young men aged between 18 and 27 are liable for conscription. If a draft bill now before Russia’s Duma is passed, all young men could face criminal liability if they do not themselves turn up at military recruitment offices if the latter have not sent them a summons.
Over the four years since Russia’s invasion of Crimea, around 10 thousand young Crimeans have been conscripted into the Russian army, with the number rising each year both of conscripts and of sentences passed on those who seek to avoid Russian military service. One young man was fined 25 thousand roubles in the autumn of 2017 and is still forced to serve a year in the army.
Russia as occupying power has generally severely curtailed freedom of speech in Crimea, with searches, prosecutions and refusals to provide re-registration driving independent media and journalists out of Crimea. Recent Crimean Human Rights Group monitoring found that 30 Ukrainian were often or always blocked. The information resources involved provide truthful information about political prisoners and major rights violations in Crimea, which is also not to Russia’s and its Roskomnadzor censor’s liking.