MENU
Documenting
war crimes in Ukraine
The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

Parliament prohibits checks on prisoners’ correspondence with lawyers68-year-old Crimean Halyna Dovhopola imprisoned in Russia for 12 years on ‘treason’ charges for supporting Ukraine Open death threats against Ukrainian political prisoner in Russian captivityRussia is brutally torturing and may kill dangerously ill Crimean Tatar political prisoner UN dismisses Russia’s attempt to blame Ukraine for the deliberate killing of over 50 Ukrainian POWs at Olenivka 15 years in Russian captivity for helping Crimean Solidarity human rights movementRussia has been mercilessly tormenting 23-year-old Marianna Checheliuk from Mariupol for over a year Russia ignores own sentences to ramp up reprisals against Crimean Tatar political prisoners Abducted Ukrainian first savagely tortured by Russian FSB, then by prison staff Russia’s reported mining of the Crimean Titanium factory 'could kill tens of thousands' New charges concocted to extend sentence of 64-year-old Oleh Prykhodko, imprisoned for opposing Russia’s occupation of Crimea Volodymyr Panasenko, victim of Ukraine’s most egregious miscarriage of justice, freed after over 16 yearsRussia blocks release of Ukrainian journalist held hostage for over a year Record 'low sentence' exposes brutal methods behind Russia’s repression in occupied Crimea Ukraine orders probe after Russian Wagner mercenaries admit to killing children and other horrific atrocities Ukrainian officials prevent former political prisoner held in Russia from returning to UkraineECHR finds Ukraine in violation over life prisoner tortured into confessing to somebody else’s crime What did the media team of the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group deal with in 2022?Ukrainian works of literature and history banned as ‘extremist’ in Russian occupied Luhansk oblast Ukrainian political prisoner’s sentence increased for contempt of Russian kangaroo court
• Topics / Penal institutions

Prisoners to pay for humanization of prisons?

27.01.2010    source: www.ukrprison.org.ua
Katya Kot
With the entry into force of Law № 2460, penal administrations have the right to retrieve through the courts the cost of keeping all prisoners who are not working. And it is no longer important whether the penal institution (the State) is providing prisoners with the opportunity to earn money or not

As reported, the Verkhovna Rada on 21 January 2010 passed a Law on amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code [CPC] and Penal Code (on ensuring protection of prisoners’ rights in penal institutions). The Law envisages a number of changes in prisoners’ conditions, including removal of any restrictions on the number of parcels prisoners may receive, of restrictions on phone calls, albeit from 2012, and certain concessions are introduced for life prisoners.

These are undoubtedly important and long-awaited improvements, bringing conditions closer to European standards. One could only welcome them, were it not for the change to Article 121 § 3 of the Penal Code. This norm had envisaged that “from prisoners who persistently shirk work, the cost of food, clothing, shoes, linen, communal, everyday and other services provided, shall be deducted from the money in their personal accounts. If there is no money in the prisoner’s account, the corrective colony has the right to file a civil claim with the court.”

This only concerned those prisoners who “persistently shirked work”, always assuming they had work.

The amendments have radically changed this, with Article 121 § 3 now reading:

“From prisoners who are not working (aside from people indicated in Article 115 § 4 of this Code), the cost of food, clothing, shoes, linen, communal, everyday and other services provided, shall be deducted from the money in their personal accounts. If there is no money in the prisoner’s account, the corrective colony has the right to file a civil claim with the court.”

With the entry into force of Law № 2460, penal administrations have the right to retrieve through the courts the cost of keeping all prisoners who are not working. And it is no longer important whether the penal institution (the State) is providing prisoners with the opportunity to earn money or not, whether the person wishes to work or not – all will have to pay for being in the colony. And from those prisoners who don’t have work, but do have money in their account, for example, from relatives, they will be able to deduct the cost of their keep. Where there is no money, the penal administration can turn to the court to have the money deducted after the prisoner’s release. And then, a person being released in present difficult conditions, sometimes without a roof over their head or the chance of finding one, without documents (the passport removed when arrested and not returned), will have to earn the money to pay for their former keep as prisoners, and all that on a court order!

It should be borne in mind that most prisoners are not without work at their choice, but because the State in 18 years has done virtually nothing to create a sufficient number of jobs in penal institutions. Now for this failure it is prisoners who will have to pay. This step by the Verkhovna Rada is in breach of Article 5 of the Penal Code which declares among principles of penal legislation the principle of mutual responsibility of State and prisoner. Making prisoners pay for the State’s failure to provide jobs is entirely irresponsible.

Furthermore, the real threat of such a court case by the administration could be a way of exerting pressure on a prisoner. It could also create the conditions for judges taking bribes to not send a person to prison, but assign another form of sentence.

Donetsk Memorial considers this change to  Article 121 § 3 of the Penal Code to be entirely unacceptable.  It is therefore calling on the President to veto the Law and suggest that the Verkhovna Rada completely abolish Article 121 § 3 of the Penal Code. We call on colleagues from other civic organizations to support us in this.

(slightly abridged)

 Share this