MENU
Documenting war crimes in Ukraine.
The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

Verkhovna Rada refuses to support trial by juryAI: Parliament must strengthen safeguards against torture in new CPCParliament advised to revise draft Criminal Procedure CodeDeals with investigators – progress or grounds for corruption?Council of Europe concerned about ill-treatment by the police and detention conditionsUN demands Russia pays Ukraine reparations as probe into Kherson war crimes begins She found out she was pregnant the day Russia invadedUK law firm launches legal action against Russia’s Wagner mercenaries over terrorism and war crimes in UkraineUN Report: Russia used civilians as human shields and carried out summary executions including of a 14-year-old Half a Year of the Full-Scale War in Kharkiv and the Kharkiv RegionThe First 150 Days of the Full-Scale War in Kharkiv and the Kharkiv RegionMissing and Detained Individuals in the Kharkiv Region: An analytical review (24 February to 23 June 2022)INCIDENTS IN KHARKIV AND THE KHARKIV REGION recorded by the KHPG during the first 120 days (24 February-23 June 2022) of Russia"s all-out war against Ukraine"They gave us no protective gear apart from a helmet and a cross" – the disabled in Ukraine’s Occupied Territories are being forced to fight On documenting international crimes committed by the Russian occupiersSummary of events that took place in Kharkiv and Kharkiv region during the first 30 days of the full-scale Russian-Ukrainian war (February 24 – March 25, 2022)Guide on the investigation of torturesReport concerning the investigation of the mass unlawful use of force to the convicts of the Oleksiivska correctional colony (No.25) on January 8, 2020 Russia brings ethnically profiled selective justice to occupied Crimea A brief description of the KHPG strategic litigations in the first half of 2021

Forward to a jury system or back to people’s assessors?

24.01.2012    source: www.radiosvoboda.org

The draft Criminal Procedure Code which the President has submitted for parliament’s consideration envisages the appearance of jury assessors. The government claims that this is the first step towards creating a jury system in Ukraine. Experts are critical, predicting a return to the Soviet model of people’s assessors.

The draft Code states that people suspected of committing particularly serious crimes will be able to demand that a court is appointed consisting of two professional judges and three «juror judges”. Candidates for the latter will be put forward by local communities.

The President of the Institute of Law Policy Mykola Onishchuk says that the model negates the very sense of a real jury. Those who earlier drew up the draft Criminal Procedure Code suggested that a jury, made up of six or twelve ordinary citizens would take decisions as to whether there had been a crime and whether the defendant was guilty.

Members of the government argue that the proposed model is merely the first stage towards a fully-fledged jury system. The chair of the parliamentary subcommittee on criminal procedure legislation, S. Oliynyk asserts that the institution is provided for in the new draft code in the form which is possible from the economic point of view.

However human right rights activists believe that the draft code effectively envisages a return to the Soviet system of court proceedings.

The Head of the Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union, Arkady Bushchenko calls it an attempt to tell people that Ukraine has a developed democracy. He points out that a jury is a panel of jurors who determine whether a person is guilty.  This does not include judges. “Now this is a single panel. They’re not jurors, however they try to call them”, he says. He adds that the attempt to convince European experts that a jury system is being introduced has not worked. The experts who analyzed the draft code also noted that it does not envisage such an institution. 

 Share this