war crimes in Ukraine

The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

‘Ukraine is not Russia’: Judge expresses opposing view over pensioner’s prison sentence for a ‘like’ Foiled by Finland, Russia forces asylum seekers to fight its war against Ukraine Young Crimean Tatar mother faces possible prison sentence for not denouncing another Ukrainian to the Russian FSB Russian FSB detains, then terrorizes and threatens to abduct young Crimean Tatar mother ‘Подвійні удари’ — росіяни цілять по рятувальниках, як робили це в СиріїKherson doctor killed in latest of almost one thousand Russian attacks on Ukraine’s healthcare system Viktoriia Ivlieva: ‘I would never defend Russia’‘Children, I won’t be able to teach the lesson because the war has started’Ensuring that Russia answers for its killing of children in Uman and countless other war crimes Russian paratrooper goes on trial in Ukraine for alleged war crimes in Kyiv oblast Russia plans huge propaganda New Year tree in Mariupol while residents freeze in bombed city Russia destroys or damages over 1100 Ukrainian hospitals and plunders othersUK law firm launches legal action against Russia’s Wagner mercenaries over terrorism and war crimes in UkraineRussia effectively admits to using Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant as a military base Conflicting values and conflicting narratives: the case of Russia’s war on UkraineRussian legislative changes would mean school leavers can officially be sent to fight in Ukraine Russia lavishly pays Wagner Unit mercenaries to bomb and kill Ukrainians International appeal: ‘Let’s not get into the wrong fight! We must support the Ukrainians without thinking twice or holding back’Oksana Stomina: This is medieval cruelty, multiplied by modern possibilities and sick, maniacal ambitionsRussian soldiers risk prison or injure themselves so as to not fight in Ukraine

When In Doubt, Blame The West

Brian Whitmore
Blaming the tragedy of Metrojet Flight 9268 on the West might work at home. But that will do little to change the dynamic that Moscow has set in motion with its Syria campaign.

Russia’s chief propagandist Dmitry Kiselev blamed the West for the downing of Metrojet Flight 9268


So Russia went there after all.

The crash of Metrojet Flight 9268 in Egypt on October 31, which killed all 224 people on board, was more than the worst aviation disaster in the country’s history.

Once it became clear that the cause of the crash was probably terrorism, it also became a messaging nightmare for the Kremlin’s propaganda machine.

Since Russia’s Syria campaign began, Kremlin officials and the state media have been framing it as a painless war that was boosting Moscow’s international prestige. All patriotic citizens needed to do was sit back and enjoy the grainy footage of terrorists being obliterated by Russia’s shiny new military machine.

The deaths of hundreds of Russian civilians threatened to change that, especially after Islamic State claimed responsibility and the evidence that a bomb -- and not technical failure -- destroyed the aircraft mounted.

Suddenly the Syria campaign wasn’t cost-free anymore.

So Russian state media did what came naturally: they blamed the West.

Sputnik got the ball rolling with a piece on November 6 claiming that "British officials have made an unseemly leap to speculate on a terrorist plot in the Russian airliner crash over Sinai last weekend." 

The story concluded: "The confidence by which these assessments of terror methodology are being made raises an even more troubling, darker question: was it really terrorists, or was it British MI6 agents palming the deed off as terrorists?"

On the same day, the conspiracy website published an article claiming that Russia had captured two "CIA assets who are believed to have masterminded the downing of Flight 9268." 

And then came Dmitry Kiselyov.

On his flagship news show Vesti Nedeli on Russian state television, the bombastic pundit suggested on November 8 that it was suspicious that after two years of U.S. air strikes against Islamic State, no American passenger planes have been targeted. And yet a Russian civilian aircraft was downed after just 40 days into Russia’s military campaign in Syria.

Kiselyov went on to suggest that the United States and its allies cut a deal with Islamic State "not to touch the civilian aircraft of the Western Coalition." He added that "dividing terrorists into good ones and bad ones is standard practice for the West. If the terrorist is targeting Russia, he’s a good terrorist and even a supporter of democracy." 

Writing on his blog,  Anton Shekhovtvov, a senior fellow at the Legatum Institute and a research associate at the Kyiv-based Institute for Euro-Atlantic Cooperation noted that "this version may seem absurd to everyone who is not prone to conspiracy theories, but it is also extremely dangerous. It means that, indeed, the consolidation of Putin’s criminal regime at home is far more important for the Kremlin than the international cooperation, and that Moscow is ready to escalate its war on the West."

The Kremlin could have used the downing of Flight 9268 to repair its relations with the West, Shekhovtvov noted. They could have made the argument that: "the Russians are fighting the war on international terrorism, and Russia and the West are in this together, hence Russia is no longer a pariah state, so do lift the sanctions and accept us to the club of the global powers."

But, of course, they chose another route.

"The Kremlin keeps on instilling anti-Western hatred into the Russian society by feeding it with conspiracy theories, and this hatred may lead to psychological acceptance of even more aggressive approach towards the West, " Shekhovtvov wrote.

"As Voltaire wrote, ’those who can make you believe absurdities, can make you commit atrocities.’"

Blaming the tragedy of Metrojet Flight 9268 on the West might work at home. But that will do little to change the dynamic that Moscow has set in motion with its Syria campaign.

"The Kremlin’s propaganda channels feted the air strikes against Syrian rebels as a sign that the country was once again a geopolitical force to be reckoned with, " veteran Kremlin-watcher Edward Lucas, author of "The New Cold War, " wrote in The Telegraph.

"But the reckoning may be a bloody one. Russia is now firmly [and probably irrevocably] positioned as an enemy of conservative and radical Sunni Muslims."

 Share this