war crimes in Ukraine

The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Crimean taken by force to Russia dies in prison, refused medical care

Halya Coynash

Right: Roman Martynovsky, photo: Hromadske Radio

One of the many Ukrainian prisoners forcibly moved to Russia after the latter invaded and occupied Crimea has died in a Russian prison, with the Russian authorities having ignored even the European Court of Human Rights.

The man had been held in a Russian prison for 2 years without receiving the medical care he required for hepatitis and tuberculosis. According to Roman Martynovsky, a lawyer from the Regional Centre for Human Rights, an application had been made at his request to the European Court of Human Rights to take urgent measures in accordance with Rule 39 of the Regulations.  The Court demanded information from Russia on the medical care the man was receiving, etc.

He was clearly receiving none and has died, with Russia yet again flouting its obligation to comply with any requests from the Court in Strasbourg.  It is similarly ignoring the Court’s demand for information about the conditions in which Yevhen Panov is being held.  He has been held by the Russian FSB in Crimea since early August and is being prevented from seeing a proper lawyer.  There are very serious grounds in his case for believing that he was subjected to torture.

Martynovsky has learned that other prisoners in the same prison colony have tried to protest over the conditions, with most specifically complaining about the lack of proper medical treatment.  Prison administrations in Russia generally refuse to allow prisoners to have their medical records with them, claiming that this is linked to confidentiality issues.

It can, in fact, prove a question of life or death since without the records, a prisoner cannot prove what illnesses he is suffering from. 

There have been numerous reports of Crimean prisoners sentenced under Ukrainian law having Russian citizenship foisted on them and being illegally ‘retried’ under Russian law.  Elvis Asanov, a life prisoner, registered his protest at such attempts on May 11 this year by slashing his throat directly in the courtroom. He thankfully survived. 

Human rights activists reported at the time that there were over a thousand Crimean prisoners who are being forced in this way to take Russian citizenship.  This is entirely illegal and also means that many of them are not freed according to Ukrainian amnesties to which they are entitled.

They made public a poignant letter written by some of the Ukrainian prisoners who wrote:

We are the same Ukrainian citizens as all other citizens of our country.  We love and honour our motherland, but often can’t understand why our motherland is so unprincipled in its attitude to our fate. Each of us has a family in Ukraine, children, parents whom we aren’t able to contact and who suffer from that, perhaps even more than we do.

 We want and hope to return home, to our loved ones. We want to work for the good of our country, yet we do not see any wish from our country to help us. Over the last two years, many of our citizens have been made Russian citizens, and are already serving sentences in Russia as Russian nationals.”

Martynovsky has stressed that there are men and women prisoners, including some who are underage.  He adds that this is a clear breach of the Geneva Conventions and can be deemed a war crime.   The problem is proving it since Russia makes it impossible to contact the people.  They are working on it, with the priority given to underage prisoners, as well as those with serious illnesses or psychological disorders. 

It is important to remember that many of those held in detention when Russia invaded Ukraine had not been convicted of any crime. 

Back in August, Martynovsky said that he could not see Russia being deterred by the threat of liability for war crimes.  Attention was therefore needed from international organizations.  He expressed surprise that Amnesty International, which does have an office in Ukraine, was silent.

Russia has also tried to foist its citizenship on Ukrainians imprisoned on politically motivated charges.  This was particularly flagrant in the case of Crimean filmmaker Oleg Sentsov and civic activist Oleksandr Kolchenko.  An application on Kolchenko’s behalf is with the European Court of Human Rights over the attempt to claim that he had ‘automatically’ become a Russian citizenship.  Sentsov has made his contempt for such efforts clear on many occasions, most memorably here:

“I also wish to protest against the attempts to deprive me of Ukrainian citizenship.  I have always been and remain a citizen of Ukraine.  I do not recognize the Russian Federation’s annexation and military seizure of the Crimea. I consider any agreements made by the illegitimate government of the Crimea with the Russian Federation invalid.  I am no serf to be passed over together with the land.  I have not written any applications to take on Russian citizenship and reject my Ukrainian citizenship. “


 Share this