MENU

Similar articles

Mass burial site at Izium, imprisoned teenagers and other Russian war crimes in Kharkiv oblast Russian horrific castration of Ukrainian POW was about terror and preventing own soldiers from surrendering Missing and Detained Individuals in the Kharkiv Region: An analytical review (24 February to 23 June 2022)Disappearances in the Zaporizhzhia Region (24 February to 18 June 2022)International experts issue stark warning of Russian genocide against UkraineRussia extends terror and abductions from occupied Crimea and Donbas to all of Ukraine Almost 400 Russian war crimes already documented in Ukraine Terror and abductions as Russia tries to break Ukrainian resistance in Kherson and other occupied cities‘To be silent means to become an accomplice,’ St. Petersburg Pen Club"s StatementRussia kills Minsk Agreement, with lives of over 300 Ukrainian hostages and POWs in danger Crucial law adopted to help Russia’s Ukrainian political prisoners and hostagesKazakhstan opposition activists beaten up and threatened with deportation by Ukraine’s Security Service Did ‘chief butcher’ of Izolyatsia secret prison in occupied Donbas work for Ukraine’s SBU? Donbas militants seize Ukrainian teacher trying to help her ailing mother Key Donbas militant asserts that Russia killed ‘Donetsk republic’ leader appointed by Putin aideVolunteer imprisoned by Donbas militants for helping orphaned children receives Ukraine’s National Human Rights Defender award Russia’s war against Ukraine is just ‘physics’, former Putin aide assertsWith Russia waging war against Ukraine, ask Zelensky why he wants impunity for war criminals ‘Chief butcher’ at Izolyatsia secret Donetsk prison confirms key role of Russian FSB, but raises questions about Ukraine’s reaction Russian mercenary who committed war crimes in Donbas receives special honour in Russia

Ukrainian rights groups unite to fight torture amid dangerous escalation in Donbas

17.01.2017
Halya Coynash

While the use of torture by law enforcement officials in areas not directly affected by the military conflict appears to have decreased, the scale of abuse and major rights violations in Russian-occupied Crimea and in the Donetsk and Luhansk oblasts has increased alarmingly since the military conflict began in 2014.  There are complaints of torture by Ukrainian soldiers or the Security Service [SBU], as well as by the Russian and pro-Russian militants.  The fact that so few agents of the state are held to answer, even where the use of force results in somebody’s death, will be one of the challenges that 12 human rights groups have united to address. 

On Jan 16, the Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union and Kharkiv Human Rights Group announced the formation of a Coalition against Torture aimed at preventing the still prevalent use of torture or ill-treatment in places of imprisonment.  12 rights groups from around the country will take part in visiting places of confinement and other activities.  The focus is very much on active prevention and help rather than simply monitoring and reporting on conditions in prisons, etc. 

The good news is that after years of sociological surveys reporting a devastatingly high public assessment of the prevalence of police torture, the results in 2015 showed a significant drop.  While in 2011, the estimated number of victims of unlawful violence by police was just short of a million, with 409 thousand considered victims of torture, the corresponding numbers for 2015 were 113,331 and 62,935.  The study has always been based on public perception, rather than hard evidence, however there is a clear movement in the right direction.  Good news can, of course, only be understood loosely when there could be as many as 63 thousand victims of torture or ill-treatment. 

One systematic problem is the failure in many SIZO [remand units] or prisons to react when prisoners urgently require medical treatment or when their state of health means that their continued imprisonment is effectively signing their death warrant.  In such cases intervention is needed immediately. 

There is also serious concern over cases where people face being forcibly sent back to countries where their life could be in danger.  The SBU has played a very strange role here. 

In September 2016, for example, the SBU effectively abducted Amina Babaeva, a 26-year-old woman who had just applied for asylum in Kharkiv and forcibly handed her over to Russia.  The same baffling level of collaboration with Russia’s FSB has been seen in SBU attempts to force 32-year-old Ruslan Meyriev, who has a Ukrainian wife and children, to agree to be deported to Russia where he is facing obviously dubious charges.  It is likely that in Meyriev’s case, as well as some others, the SBU has influenced Ukraine’s Migration Service into refusing applications for asylum.   It is human rights organizations who have thus far foiled such attempts, mainly by turning to the European Court of Human Rights to intervene.  

The work of the Coalition must inevitably be coloured by the military conflict in Donbas and ongoing occupation and mounting repression in Crimea.  The scale of the violations in eastern Ukraine and Russian-occupied Crimea, including summary executions and forced disappearances, has increased since 2014, with a level of brutalization and acceptance of violence.  In general, the Coalition believe that there must be a policy of zero tolerance for any form of torture, but there is a particular need to address both the brutality and impunity for there to be any hope of future reintegration of areas now under occupation. 

 

 

 

 

 Share this