war crimes in Ukraine

The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

Russia resorts to open terrorization of lawyers & their families in occupied CrimeaRussian FSB stage abduction to deprive Crimean Tatar leader of his lawyerRussia prepares new criminal charges as Crimean Tatar leader refuses to be silencedClosed ‘court’ in Russian-occupied Crimea moves to strip Crimean Tatar leader of his lawyerUmerov Released: Only Russia’s Persecution Showed PathologyPro-Kremlin Media Lies as International Pressure Mounts to Free UmerovRussia steps up torture of Crimean Tatar leader Ilmi Umerov amid protest over return of punitive psychiatryPunitive Psychiatry against Crimean Tatar leader for insisting Russia must leave CrimeaCrimean Tatar Mejlis Leader Arrested on ‘Extremism’ ChargesRussia bans Mejlis, declares war on Crimean Tatar people while the West watchesSanctions, not words, needed over extrajudicial criminalization of the Crimean Tatar MejlisRussia abandons all pretence, ’suspends’ Crimean Tatar Representative AssemblyRussia Declares War on Crimean Tatars2,300 directly at risk if Russia bans Crimean Tatar Representative BodyCrimean Tatar Mejlis criminalized for opposing Russian occupation of CrimeaRussia seeks to ban Crimean Tatar Representative Assembly as ‘extremist’Russia accuses Crimean Tatar leaders of recruiting for Islamic State‘Anti-terrorist exercises’ as latest intimidation of Crimean TatarsKremlin creates agency for national minorities as it axes Crimean Tatar mediaCrimean Tatar TV silenced, searches and arrests continue

Dirty Russian Media Lies as Repression Mounts in Occupied Crimea

Halya Coynash
While armed searches and arrests were underway in Russian-occupied Crimea of a prominent human rights lawyer and the son of a veteran of the Crimean Tatar national movement, Russian state-controlled media widely reported that a “special operation” was underway against supposed ‘terrorists’.

While armed searches and arrests were underway in Russian-occupied Crimea of a prominent human rights lawyer and the son of a veteran of the Crimean Tatar national movement, Russian state-controlled media widely reported that a “special operation” was underway against supposed ‘terrorists’. 

Although the two searches on Thursday were carried out with large numbers of armed and masked men, both men who were detained – human rights defender and lawyer Emil Kurbedinov and civic activist Seiran Saliyev – were charged only with administrative offences. 

The detention of Emil Kurbedinov and the subsequent court hearing in which he was jailed for 10 days for a  totally innocuous video clip posted on the social network VKontakte a year before Russia’s annexation of Crimea are very clearly part of a concentrated offensive against Ukrainian and Russian lawyers defending victims of persecution (details here). 

Kurbedinov was detained when he and fellow lawyer Edem Semedlyaev were on their way to the home of Seiran Saliyev where a search was underway.  Saliyev is one of 5 Crimean Tatars who have faced administrative fines on preposterous charges after they came out onto the street during the searches and arrests on May 12, 2016 of four Crimean Tatars on fabricated charges linked with an organization which is legal in Ukraine. Saliyev was convicted of ‘organizing an unauthorized mass protest’ for using the Mosque loudspeaker to inform people that the searches were being carried out.

This time, Saliyev was taken away by the FSB and brought before a Russian-controlled court on Thursday afternoon.  He was charged under two articles of the Code of Administrative Offences with ‘circulating extremist material’ (20.29) and public demonstration of symbols, etc. of an extremist organization (20.3). 

He has been sentenced to 12 days’ administrative arrest. 

The supposed ‘extremist’ material, like with Kurbedinov’s 4-year-old post on VKontakte, was presumably connected, though perhaps tenuously, with the pan-Islamist movement Hizb ut-Tahrir.  Russia declared it ‘terrorist’ in 2003 without providing any evidence to back this.  The organization is, as mentioned, legal in Ukraine and there is no evidence that it has committed acts of terrorism anywhere in the world. 

Nonetheless, Russia constantly arrests men and sentences them to huge sentences or even life imprisonment for alleged involvement in the organization.  Kurbedinov is one of the lawyers who has actively publicized information about the flawed nature of the prosecutions in Crimea over supposed links with Hizb ut-Tahrir. 

Kurbedinov and Saliyev were the only two men to face searches and dubious court rulings on Jan 26.  The Russian media, however, widely spread a report which claimed that a “special operation to eliminate a Hizb ut-Tahrir cell’ was underway in Bakhchysarai.  RIA Novosti cited Zaur Smirnov, one of the few Crimean Tatars who chose to collaborate with the occupation regime and now holds a post in the Russian-controlled Crimean government. 

He claimed that a “systematic battle was being waged in Crimea against terrorist and extremist organizations” and deliberately misrepresented Hizb ut-Tahrir’s views to try to give them a ‘terrorist’ colouring.

It is likely that this disinformation offensive was launched because it is so very clear in Crimea that the Russian FSB are targeting human rights or civic activists, and other people with a strong civic position and pinning grotesque charges of, for example, seeking a violent overthrow of the Russian system.

RIA Novosti mentioned, and REN-TV even showed some kind of FSB video purporting to linked with the arrest of something referred to as a Hizb ut-Tahrir group in Tatarstan.  It is claimed that the group was planning terrorist acts. 

There has never been anything to implicate Hizb ut-Tahrir members in terrorism and the renowned Memorial Human Rights Centre considers all those convicted only of membership of the organization to be political prisoners.  It has especially condemned the prosecutions in Crimea since Russia has no right to try people under Russian legislation on occupied territory over unproven involvement in an organization which is legal in Ukraine.

The FSB regularly accuses men they are holding incommunicado and without lawyers of ‘terrorist plans’.  The charges are almost invariably backed only by ‘confessions’ with no hard facts or proof, and scepticism with respect to the group in Kazan (Tatarstan) seems fully warranted.

Suspicion is also justified regarding the motives of the Russian media in so flagrantly lying about the illegal harassment and imprisonment of a human rights lawyer and civic activist in occupied Crimea.  


Photo of search - Anton Naumlyuk


 Share this