MENU
Documenting
war crimes in Ukraine

The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

Nariman Dzhelyal illegally taken to Russia in revenge for Crimean Tatar affirmation that Crimea is Ukraine Russia tortures nine Ukrainians from Kherson for grotesque ‘international terrorism trial’ Openly faked ‘evidence in Russia’s ‘trial’ of tortured Ukrainian abducted from occupied MelitopolMoscow revives Stalin’s SMERSH to hunt down resistance in occupied UkraineVolodymyr Dudka: 14 years of torment in Russian captivity for being Ukrainian in occupied Crimea EU imposes sanctions over torture and persecution of Ukrainian journalist Vladislav Yesypenko, Nariman Dzhelyal and others in Russian-occupied CrimeaUkrainians in occupied territory refused life-saving insulin unless they take Russian citizenshipTwo years of open attack on Crimean Tatars, with even political prisoners' families and lawyers jailed Russia has killed two Ukrainian political prisoners and is endangering at least 21 others Russia increases revenge sentences against Crimean Tatar Mejlis leader Nariman Dzhelyal and two cousins Russia carries out mass arrests, including of Crimean Solidarity Coordinator and journalist Lutfiye Zudiyeva Four Crimeans sentenced in FSB remake of Russia's first Ukrainian show trial against Oleh Sentsov Abducted Ukrainian first savagely tortured by Russian FSB, then by prison staff Arrested for protest over Russia’s war against Ukraine, sentenced to 10 years for ‘sabotage’Ukrainian volunteer tortured by Russian FSB to fake evidence for ‘international terrorism’ show trial Russia escalates torture conditions against imprisoned Crimean Tatar leader Nariman Dzhelyal Russian invaders abduct Ukrainian volunteer caring for elderly grandmother in occupied MelitopolRussia seizes another Ukrainian in occupied Crimea on unprovable ‘sabotage’ charges Russia plans life sentences for charges used against Ukrainian political prisoners and opponents of its war in UkraineRussia’s FSB come for elderly Crimean Tatar National Congress delegate in hunt for ‘saboteurs’

Russian FSB tortures three Ukrainians for ‘saboteur plot’ arrests in occupied Crimea

09.02.2024   
Halya Coynash
Implausible elements in Volodymyr Bodnar’s supposed ‘confession’ and other details make it near certain that this is the latest FSB ‘Ukrainian saboteur’ case based on torture and fabricated ‘evidence’
From left Oksana Shevchenko,, Volodymyr Bodnar , V. Ananiev From the FSB material passed to Russian media
From left Oksana Shevchenko,, Volodymyr Bodnar , V. Ananiev From the FSB material passed to Russian media
Russia’s FSB claimed on 5 February 2024 to have thwarted yet another supposed ‘saboteur plot’ in occupied Crimea.  As always, the only evidence is in ‘confessions’ almost certainly given under duress by two men and a women held totally under the control of Russia’s security service. The latter claimed that they had prevented what they described as a “terrorist attack” by Ukraine’s Security Service [SBU] against one of the Russian-installed ‘leaders’ of occupied Crimea, with the three people, described as “Russian citizens”, supposedly planning to blow up a car from the said ‘leader’s’ cortege.  

The three people are identified as Volodymyr Bodnar (b. 1974); his wife Oksana Shevchenko, and a second man, identified only by surname and initials V.V. AnanievPhotos from the FSB video are shown of all three, with Ananiev described as disabled and walking with a stick.  Although the Russian state media claim that all three admit to the charges, only Bodnar is shown ‘confessing’.

During this brief ‘confession’, Bodnar gets flustered in one place, as though unable to remember what he should say, while elsewhere his speech is suspiciously smooth, as though he is reciting a learned text. That impression is also strengthened when he repeats part of his story.  He explains that he was born in Zaporizhzhia on 12 April 1974 and is registered in that city.  He was supposedly told by SBU officers to take “an explosive device of American or German make” to Melitopol which he allegedly did.  He claims that he cut a hole out of a gas cannister and placed what he calls ‘a mine’ in it, wrapped this in a rag and carried it to Crimea.

No mention is made of the fact that Zaporizhzhia remains under government control, while Melitopol in Zaporizhzhia oblast and Crimea are both under Russian occupation.  It is unclear how Bodnar would have even been able to get through Russian checkpoints, let alone smuggle in ‘an explosive device’ wrapped in a rag. Yet at least one of the Russian/pro-Russian media report that, according to Shevchenko, her husband took the device to occupied Crimea back in May 2023 and hid it in a rented garage.  Then in October 2023, he purportedly received SBU instructions to detonate the device near one of the cars in the cortege of one of the leaders of Crimea.  They were purportedly planning to carry this out from 26 January to 1 February 2024, but were detained by the FSB. She also claimed that her husband had been recruited by the SBU after being detained by SBU officers when trying to pass through the Vasylivka checkpoint.

The FSB claimed to have removed a homemade explosive device, as well as a remote control which was supposed to detonate the device through a phone call.  Videos in which FSB operatives are shown allegedly ‘finding’ weapons, explosives, telephones, etc. have been part of the repertoire since 2014, with essentially no possibility of verifying the supposed discoveries.  In at least one case, Oleksiy Stohniy, from Sevastopol, was shown being violently ‘detained’ in broad daylight although it is known that he was seized at night.

The three Ukrainians have been charged under Article 205 § 2 a, (and Article 30 § 1) of Russia’s criminal code – attempt to commit an act of terrorism, as well as Article 222.1 § 3a (unlawful possession, etc. of weapons, explosive devices, etc.).  While there is no possibility of independently verifying the ‘evidence’ for such charges, the implausibility of part of the ‘plot’ are already grounds for doubting them. 

The other reason for scepticism is that this is one of very many such stories where the FSB claim to have ‘thwarted’ terrorist attacks, with no ‘evidence’ except that provided by men and women held incommunicado, without access to independent lawyers.   Nariman Dzhelyal, world-renowned Crimean Tatar Mejlis leader and journalist is just one of many Ukrainians imprisoned in Russia on preposterous ‘sabotage’ charges, based solely on ‘confessions’ which both Asan and Aziz Akhtemov retracted, as given under savage torture, as soon as they were allowed to see proper lawyers. 

Information about Nariman Dzhelyal, Asan and Aziz Akhtemov

Nariman Dzhelyal illegally taken to Russia in revenge for Crimean Tatar affirmation that Crimea is Ukraine

Volodymyr Dudka, Oleksiy Bessarabov and Dmytro Shtyblikov

Russia wanted a new ‘Crimean saboteur trial’, so they looked around for three Ukrainians

Iryna Danilovich

Imprisoned Ukrainian civic journalist Iryna Danilovych may have suffered a stroke due to Russian medical torture

The above are only some of a very large, and ever-increasing, number of Ukrainian citizens imprisoned on fake ‘Ukrainian saboteur’ charges.

 Share this