Menu
• The right to a fair trial   • Events
18 November 2026

The Yulia Tymoshenko Case: Amicus Curiae Brief by Former ECtHR Judges and an Independent Assessment by ROLE

This publication presents the Amicus Curiae brief by former ECtHR judges Yonko Grozev and Armen Harutyunyan in the criminal case concerning Yulia Tymoshenko. It also presents an independent peer review of the brief by the international organisation ROLE. The documents focus on possible violations of the right to a fair trial (Article 6 ECHR), in particular the defence’s access to evidence, the examination of prosecution witnesses, possible entrapment, and signs that the prosecution has an ulterior political purpose.

Tymoshenko Timoshenko

The Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group (KHPG) is monitoring the criminal proceedings against Yulia Tymoshenko, a Member of the Ukrainian Parliament. In the course of our monitoring, we have identified a number of circumstances indicating possible violations of international human rights standards at the pre-trial investigation stage, particularly the right to a fair trial guaranteed by Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Of particular concern are restrictions on the defence’s access to evidence, difficulties in examining key prosecution witnesses, indications of possible entrapment, and circumstances suggesting that the criminal prosecution may be pursuing an ulterior political purpose.

Given the seriousness of these problems, KHPG approached two renowned international experts and former judges of the European Court of Human Rights, Yonko Grozev and Armen Harutyunyan. We asked them to prepare an independent expert opinion for the High Anti-Corruption Court of Ukraine in the form of an Amicus Curiae brief. The purpose of this document is to help the national court assess the circumstances of the case in line with the standards of the European Convention on Human Rights and the case law of the ECtHR. It also identifies the issues that require judicial examination and possible ways of remedying them.

Yonko Grozev is a Bulgarian lawyer and a well-known specialist in international human rights law. He served as a judge of the ECtHR from 2015 to 2024 and as a Section President of the Court from 2020 to 2023. Before his election as a judge, he practised as a lawyer for more than twenty years, representing applicants in human rights cases before national courts and the ECtHR. He took part in many strategic cases concerning freedom of expression, politically motivated persecution, the right to a fair trial and other fundamental rights.

Armen Harutyunyan is an Armenian lawyer and Doctor of Laws. He served as a judge of the ECtHR from 2015 to 2025. From 2006 to 2011 he was the Ombudsman of Armenia and also served as Armenia’s deputy representative to the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe. From 2011 to 2014 he was Regional Representative of the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights for Central Asia, and from 2014 to 2015 he headed the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine. He has many years of experience in constitutional law, the international protection of human rights and the reform of legal institutions.

The experts’ Amicus Curiae Brief for the High Anti-Corruption Court of Ukraine in the Case of Criminal Investigation and Charges against Yulia Tymoshenko contains an independent legal analysis of the case file. The authors draw attention to four key issues: the defence’s access to evidence, the right to examine prosecution witnesses, possible entrapment, and the alleged ulterior political purpose of the prosecution. They stress that the national court must properly examine and remedy these shortcomings, as otherwise they may lead to a violation of the right to a fair trial.

To obtain an independent expert assessment of the Amicus Curiae brief, KHPG also approached the international organisation Rule of Law Empowerment (ROLE). ROLE carried out a peer review, independently assessing the brief’s consistency with the standards of the Convention and the case law of the ECtHR.

ROLE is an international expert organisation headquartered in Strasbourg. It was founded by former ECtHR judges, leading lawyers and experienced specialists from Europe and the United States. Its work aims to strengthen the rule of law, judicial independence and the protection of human rights, primarily in the young democracies of Europe and Central Asia. ROLE monitors court proceedings, prepares independent legal opinions, and supports strategic litigation and human rights organisations. The President of ROLE is Anna Maralyan, a lawyer specialising in the international protection of human rights and in court proceedings.

In a covering letter dated 23 September 2026, the President of ROLE, Anna Maralyan, stated that the organisation had carried out an independent peer review of the Amicus Curiae brief. She said ROLE endorses its main conclusions and considers them well founded in the standards of the European Convention on Human Rights, the case law of the ECtHR and the facts set out in the document.

In its review, ROLE places particular emphasis on several points. The defence must be given a genuine opportunity to verify the authenticity and integrity of the key audio recording and to examine the prosecution witnesses. The allegations of entrapment must be examined in full. The circumstances that may indicate an ulterior political purpose behind the prosecution must also be investigated (https://share.google/evNj0SlUhVDebGAm2).

KHPG is publishing both documents in a single file: the Amicus Curiae brief by Yonko Grozev and Armen Harutyunyan, and ROLE’s independent expert review. They are intended for judges, lawyers, human rights defenders, journalists and anyone interested in whether Ukraine is upholding international human rights standards.

Download the PDF files:

share the information

Similar articles

• Events

Bail that cannot be paid is not bail. Statement by human rights organisations.

A court sets bail, but banks block payment into the High Anti-Corruption Court's account, and the person remains in a pre-trial detention centre. Human rights organisations are calling on the National Bank of Ukraine to put an end to this practice, recalling the positions of the ECtHR and the Constitutional Court: the possibility of release on bail must be real, not illusory.

• The right to a fair trial

Ukrainian mother sentenced to five years for helping her family survive and escape Russian occupation

The unwarranted charges and sentence for supposed collaboration send a chilling message to all those Ukrainians waiting for liberation after long years of Russian occupation

• Events   • Against torture and ill-treatment

Russia confirms torture is state policy through withdrawal from vital European Convention

Russia’s withdrawal from a Convention against Torture which it stopped complying with even minimally in 2022 will not absolve it from liability for its violations, but it is a telling statement

• Events   • War crimes

Russian court sentences Memorial Head to 6 years for calling persecuted Ukrainian POWs political prisoners

Russia will not, at least, be able to execute its sentence against Sergei Davidis, unlike the Azov POWs and hundreds of other Ukrainian prisoners of war and political prisoners