MENU
Documenting
war crimes in Ukraine

The Tribunal for Putin (T4P) global initiative was set up in response to the all-out war launched by Russia against Ukraine in February 2022.

Similar articles

Russia passes huge conveyor belt sentences against Ukrainians tortured for propaganda videos Russia-Ukraine war: what does filtration mean?18-year-old Russian imprisoned for Shevchenko poem on anniversary of Russia’s full-scale invasion of UkraineSentenced to 17 years in Siberia for opposing Russia's invasion and affirming that Crimea is Ukraine Execution or Siberian labour camp for opposing Russia’s occupation of Ukrainian territory Son of Crimean Tatar political prisoner dies, deprived by Russia of his father in life and in deathArmed raid and surreal charges in Russian attempt to silence renowned Crimean Tatar journalist and Crimean Solidarity coordinator Lutfiye Zutfiyeva Russia's armed terror against independent Crimean Tatar Muslim community hits resistance Insane sentence and 18 months of agonizing silence after Russia abducts two friends for opposing its war against Ukraine Ukrainian journalist abducted, tortured and sentenced to 13 years for writing about Russia’s invasion of Ukraine Russian FSB tortures three Ukrainians for ‘saboteur plot’ arrests in occupied Crimea Russian propaganda turns the elimination of its officials in occupied Lysychansk into ‘a monstrous attack on a bakery’Huge mass ‘sentences’ after fake trial of Ukrainian POWs whom Russia accused of its own war crimes Russia has turned Crimea into a huge prison for political prisoners and hostages from Kherson and Zaporizhzhia oblastsHorrific sentences against Crimean Solidarity journalists for telling the world of Russia’s crimes in occupied Crimea Prison for ‘likes’ in the social networks? How people are punished in Ukraine for justifying Russian aggressionRussia tortures nine Ukrainians from Kherson for grotesque ‘international terrorism trial’ Russia moves to confiscate possessions for condemning its war against Ukraine or for opposing occupation of Crimea Openly faked ‘evidence in Russia’s ‘trial’ of tortured Ukrainian abducted from occupied MelitopolA Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group successful action in 1991

On interpreting statistics

02.08.2007   
According to the Minister of Justice, the number of low income Ukrainians needing free legal aid has decreased. And not just a little. Human rights groups would respectfully suggest an alternative interpretation for the statistics cited

According to the Minister of Justice, the number of low income Ukrainians needing free legal aid has decreased. And not just a little … The Minister believes that in comparison with 2005, the number of such citizens in 2007 has decreased by at least one third.  

The reason for this somewhat startling conclusion is to be found in the Ministry’s reporting on State-funded legal assistance in criminal cases.

The Minister explains this “achievement” as follows:

In recent years the State Budget has annually allocated 1960.9 thousand UAH for legal aid in criminal proceedings.

Now whereas in 2005 the Ministry actually paid out 2337 thousand UAH in 1927 criminal cases, in 2006 – 163,7 thousand UAH in 1,591 criminal cases, in the first half of 2007, lawyers presented bills to be paid amounting to 48,6 thousand UAH in 512 criminal cases.

The Minister stated that these statistics were a fairly objective indicator since money is paid out according to lawyers’ bills.

Only what does the indicator indicate?

Nobody is disputing the statistics, only the quantum leap made in determining a radical change in the number of people who need legal aid.

The situation with legal aid in Ukraine is, in fact, highly unsatisfactory.  The Constitution clearly states that “Everyone has the right to legal assistance. Such assistance is provided free of charge in cases envisaged by law” (Article 59).  At present, however, State funding is only allocated for legal aid in criminal proceedings.

The amounts allocated are far from adequate, and yet in most regions they are not spent in full.  This is not the paradox it may seem.  A lawyer working for a full day providing such legal aid earns the princely sum of 15 UAH (around 3 USD).  Not only is this amount less than reasonable remuneration, but the lawyer needs to spend a considerable amount of time, paper and nerves to extract his or her honest earnings.  This may explain why the number of lawyers rearing to offer their services in some areas leads to money available and not spent.

It unfortunately also probably explains why the quality of legal aid is not always as could be wished. One need not necessarily criticize mercenary lawyers – they may simply be forced to deal with too many cases to themselves make ends meet.

The Minister of Justice would be well advised to view the work of the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group’s Legal Aid Centre for Victims of Ill-treatment or the Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union’s Legal Assistance Fund for Victims of Human Rights Abuse.  While these are more specific in their focus, the human rights groups have found no reason to believe that the need in society for free legal aid has diminished.

 Share this